No Detail Found!

Quackery in Health is Still Around: Pseudoscienti c Healing Practices Across the Globe

Author(s)
Ghulam Yaseen Veesar Department of Informatics and Health Management, Institute of Business Management,Karachi,Pakistan
Ather Akhlaq Department of Informatics and Health Management, Institute of Business Management,Karachi,Pakistan
Ahson Qavi Siddiqi Anti-Quackery Committee, Sindh Healthcare Commission,Karachi,Pakistan
Abdul Ghafoor Shoro Anti-Quackery Committee, Sindh Healthcare Commission,Karachi,Pakistan
Abstract
Fraudulent medical practices remain prevalent globally, fueled by digital platforms spreading false claims. This study analysed 3,327 published studies and 400 grey literature sources, selecting 38 studies and 19 excerpts for detailed examination. It identi ed 126 distinct quackery techniques and products used throughout history. Traditional methods are considered legitimate in Asian and African regions and dismissed as quackery in the West. In Western countries, quacks often use electricity, mechanical instruments, and gadgets for treatment. Historically, faith-based treatments are practised globally. However, these were limited to Asia and Africa. The rise of the internet has enabled quacks to exploit digital platforms to deceive and attract victims. These ndings highlight the persistence of quackery and underscore the need for targeted strategies to combat these deceptive practices globally.
Publication Details
Page(s) 83-89
Published Journal: Journal of College of Physicians and Surgeons--Pakistan : JCPSP, Volume: 35, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Quackery, Medical fraud, Charlatan, Illegal treatment
References
Janes CR .1999 .The health transition, global modernity and the crisis of traditional medicine: The tibetan case. Soc Sci Med, 9536(99) : 00082-9.
Kreidler M.,Quackery M. .2009 .. , : .
Sec CPG .2021 .search-fda-guidance-documents/cpg-sec-120500-health-fraud-factors-considering-regulatory-action.. FDA, : .
Younes R. . .The doctors selling bogus treatments to people facing blindness. BBC News, : .
Singh H,Aggarwal R,Rishi B.,Patanjali Ayurved B. .2022 .Limited: Role reversal in competitive advertising. Emeral Emerg Mark Case Stud, 10(2) : 1-28.
Northcott C,Spooner H,Joshua TB .2024 .Megachurch leader raped and tortured worshippers, BBC nds. BBC News, 67749215 : .
Arksey H,O'Malley L H . .Scoping studies: Towards a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res, 10(1) : 19-32.
Trivedi M. .2009 .A study of search engines for health sciences. Int J Lib Inf Sci, 10(68) : 62-73.
Azodi AA,Setayesh M,Bazyar M,Ansari M,Yazdi-Feyzabadi V .2024 .Causes and consequences of quack medicine in health care: A scoping review of global experience. BMC Health Serv Res, 10(1) : 64.
Gogtay NJ,Bhatt HA,Dalvi SS,Kshirsagar NA .2002 .The use and safety of non-allopathic Indian medicines. Drug saf, 10(14) : 1005-19.
Liebermen JJ,Lieberman SJ .1975 .A short history of quackery and byways in medicine. Am Biol Teach, 10(1) : 39-43.
Kao A .2000 .Medical quackery: The pseudo-science of health and well-being. AMA J Ethics, 2(4) : imhl1-0004.
Slashinski MJ,McCurdy SA,Achenbaum LS,Whitney SN,McGuire AL .2012 .Snake-oil, quack medicine, and industrially cultured organisms: Biovalue and the commercialisation of human microbiome research. BMC Med Ethics, 10 : 1472.
Watson LR .2013 .Tom Tiddler s ground: Irregular medical practitioners and male sexual problems in New Zealand,. Med Hist, 38(4) : 537-58.
Ndububa VI .2007 .Medical quackery in Nigeria; Why the silence?. Niger J Med, 10(4) : 37328-7.
Rolleston H .1927 .Irregular practice and quackery. Can Med Assoc J, 17(5) : 501-8.
Lingo AK .1986 .Empirics and charlatans in early modern France: The genesis of the classi cation of the other in medical practice. J Soc Hist, 10(4) : 583-603.
Smith L .2008 .Sex and quacks in the 1 8th century. J Fam Plann Reprod Health Care, 10(1) : 63-4.
Humagain M,Bhattarai BP,Rokaya D. .2020 .Quackery in dental practice in Nepal. J Nepal Med Assoc, 10(227) : 543-6.
Lerner IJ .1981 .Laetrile: A lesson in cancer quackery. CA Cancer J Clin, 10(2) : 91-5.
Mollel MH,Mujuru M,Mjimba V,Darangwa N,Nyanzi R .2020 .Moringa olei ra noise: Science or quackery and the way forward. Afr J Sci Technol Innov Dev, 1732078(3) : 273-81.
Lavorgna A,Carr L .2021 .Tweets and quacks: Network and content analyses of providers of non-science-based anticancer treatments and their supporters on twitter. Sage Open, 10(1) : .
Virdi J .2019 .Finger surgery for deafness: Rethinking quackery in medical history. Can Med Assoc J, 10(7) : E192-4.
Young KJ . .Politics ahead of patients: The battle between medical and chiropractic professional associations over the inclusion of chiropractic in the American medicare system. Can Bull Med Hist2019; 36, 10(2) : 022019-412.
Sindh Health Care Commission. SHCC .2022 .. , : .
Ryan M. .1945 .The quack doctor of Serpukhov. Br Med J, 10(6280) : 1945-6.
Sullivan-Fowler M .1995 .Doubtful theories, drastic therapies: Autointoxication and faddism in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. J Hist Med Allied Sci, 10(3) : 364-90.
Ramsey M. .1977 .Medical power and popular medicine: Illegal healers in nineteenth-century France. J Soc Hist, 10(4) : 560-87.
Renckens CNM,Dorlo TPC .2013 .Please, let not Western quackery replace traditional medicine in Africa. Trop Med Int Health, 10(2) : 242-4.
Young JH .1961 .American medical quackery in the age of the common man. J Am Hist, 10(4) : 579-93.
Brown PS .1983 .. Bristol Med Chir J, 98(366) : 61-4.
Sullivan-Fowler M. .1996 .The giver of oxygen: Hercules sanche and the oxydonor. J Med Hum, 10(1) : 31-43.
Freedho Y. .2009 .From plunger to Punkt-roller: A century of weight-loss quackery. Can Med Assoc J, 10(4) : 432-3.
Milstead KL,Davis JB,Dobelle M. .1964 .Quackery in the medical device eld. Phys Ther, 10(7) : 654-62.
Lillestol K,Schiotz A .2011 .Illegitimate children and the medical sciences" quackery in Tidsskriftet 1990-24. Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen, 10(24) : 2512-6.
Miner JW .1966 .The costs of quackery. Phys Ther, 10(12) : 1318-21.
Hionidou V .2016 .An oral history approach. Med Hist, 57(4) : 492-513.
Meena M,Patel P,Saini S,Gurjar T,Gogoi R,Meena OP .2019 .Go mutra (Cow urine) and its uses: An overview. J Entomol Zool Stud, 7(3) : 1218-22.
Mahajan SP,Chavan SA,Shinde SA,Narkhede MB .2020 .Miraculous bene ts of cow urine: A review. J Drug Deliv Ther, 10 : 275-81.
Sherra K,Shahda M,Khalil D. .2017 .The role of culture and faith healers in the treatment of mood disorders in ruralversus urban areas in United Arab Emirates. Egypt J Psychiatry, 10(2) : 209678-1105.
Teal .2014 .A. Quacks and hacks: Georgian medicine and the power of advertising. Lancet, 6736(14) : 60141-0.
Jahangiry L,Pashaei T,Ponnet K. .2021 .Attitudes toward female genital mutilation/circumcision: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Healthcare, 10(9) : 1184.
Byers J. Quackery .1911 .: With special reference to female complaints. Br Med J, 10(2630) : 1239-42.
Milosz . ./does-breast-enlargement-cream-work/.. zwivel 2024, : .
Rynearson EH .1974 .Americans love hogwash. Nutr Rev, 10(suppl 1) : 4887-4.
Momina A,Anwar S,Tarin E. . .Punjab healthcare Commission s regulation of general practitioners of allopathic medicine. Ann King Edw Med Univ2016; 22, 10(1) : 800.
Perls TT .2004 .Anti-aging quackery: Human growth hormone and tricks of the trade-more dangerous than ever. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci, 10(7) : 682-91.
Hornberger J .2019 .Who is the fake one now? Questions of quackery, worldliness and legitimacy. Crit Public Health, 1602719(4) : 484-93.
Ryan DH,Parkin CG,Longley W,Dixon J,Apovian C,Bode B C .2018 .E cacy and safety of an oral device to reduce food intake and promote weight loss. Obes Sci Pract, 4(1) : 139-61.
Leino V,Airaksinen R,Viluksela M .2020 .Vahakangas K. Toxicity of colloidal silver products and their marketing claims in Finland. Toxicol Rep, 12 : 106-13.
Ross N. .2018 .We ve had enough of experts: the enduring charm of quackery. Br J Psychiatry, 64(5) : 265-8.
Vasanthan J,Gurusamy N,Rajasingh S,Sigamani V,Kirankumar S,Thomas EL .2021 .Role of human mesenchymal stem cells in regenerative therapy. Cells, 10(1) : 54.
.2024 .Energy muse jewelry inc. Healing gemstone and crystal bracelets. Energy Muse, : .
Ellis RR . .com/pain-management/ magnetic- eld-therapy-overview.. , : .
Davidson K,West H K .2023 .Colloidal silver: Uses, safety, and side e ects. Healthline, : .
Hesketh T,Zhu WX .1997 .Health in China. Traditional Chinese medicine: One country, two systems. BMJ, 10(7100) : 115-7.
Bloom G,Kanjilal B,Peters DH .2008 .Regulating health care markets in China and India. doi: 10.1377%2Fhltha .27.4, 27(4) : 952.
Lohar DR. .2007 .Legal status of ayurvedic siddha and unani medicine. Dept of AYUSH, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, : .
Samal J .2015 .Role of AYUSH workforce, therapeutics, and principles in health care delivery with special reference to national rural health mission. Ayu, 10(1) : 169010-8520.
Kazemi AH .2018 .. Traditional medicine/Herbal medicine situation in Iran. Chin J Pharmacol Toxicol, 32(4) : 245-7.
Khan R,Mustufa MA,Hussain S. .2020 .Factors contributing to the public proneness towards quacks in Sindh. Pan Afr Med J, 37 : 174.
. .?option=com_content& view=article&id=123&lang=en.. , : .
Steve A. .2018 .-practices-that-doctors-thought-were-good/.. Historycollection.com, : .
Wendling M. .2022 .The truth about medbeds - a miracle cure that doesn t exist. BBC News, 64070190 : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

86

Views