No Detail Found!

Sustainable Weed Management in Wheat Farming: A Comparison of Cultural Cross-Drill Strategy and Chemical Methods

Author(s)
Ehtesham Ul Haq Plant Genetic Resources Institute (PGRI), National Agriculture Research Center,Islamabad-45500,Pakistan
Iqtidar Hussain Department of Agronomy Faculty of Agriculture, Gomal University,D.I. Khan,Pakistan
Shakeel Ahmad Jatoi Plant Genetic Resources Institute (PGRI), National Agriculture Research Center,Islamabad-45500,Pakistan
Muhammad Jawad Nazir Plant Genetic Resources Institute (PGRI), National Agriculture Research Center,Islamabad-45500,Pakistan
Abstract
Weed infestation is a significant challenge in wheat farming, impacting crop productivity and food security. While chemical herbicides are widely used, their continuous application has led to concerns about weed resistance and environmental sustainability. This study, conducted during the 2019-2020 Rabi season at the Arid Zone Research Centre (AZRC), Dera Ismail Khan, Pakistan, aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of cultural and chemical weed management practices for wheat farming. The region is characterized by heavy clay soil, an alkaline pH of 8.6, low organic matter, and nutrient deficiencies, with temperatures ranging from 4°C to 42°C and frequent drought conditions. The experimental treatments included a control, crossdrilling (15×15 cm spacing), chemical herbicides (Clincher, Walter Super, Buctril Super, Super Power Killer, and Ally Max), and hand weeding. The cross-drill treatment (15×15 cm) recorded the highest grain yield (7.59 t/ha), biomass yield (7596.7 kg/ha), number of spikes (512 spikes m²), and grains per spike (33.3 grainsspike-2), with the highest benefit-cost ratio. Herbicide treatments improved wheat performance moderately, but the control plot, which had no weed management, produced the lowest yield (6.87 t ha-1) and spike count (172 spikes m²). The crop growth rate (CGR) was the highest under the cross-drill treatment (26.97 g m² day-1) compared to the control (13.47 g m² day-1). These results demonstrate that the cross-drill method is an effective and eco-friendly alternative to herbicides for minimizing weed competition and enhancing wheat productivity. This approach offers a sustainable solution to weed management challenges, reducing reliance on chemical herbicides and mitigating environmental impacts.
Publication Details
Page(s) 111-120
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences, Volume: 62, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
weed management, Sustainable agriculture, Herbicides, wheat farming, mechanical practices
References
Abbas G.,Ali M.A.,Abbas Z.,Aslam M.,Makram M. .2009 .Impact of different herbicides on broadleaf weeds and yield of wheat. Pakistan Journal of Weed Science Research, 15 : 1-10.
Abbas M.A. .2006 .General agriculture. Field crop production and management. , : 174.
Abbas T.,Zahir Z.A.,Naveed M.,Abbas S.,Alwahibi M.S.,Elshikh M.S.,Mustafa A. .2020 .Large scale screening of rhizospheric allelopathic bacteria and their potential for the biocontrol of wheat associated weeds. Agronomy, 10 : 1469.
Ahmad R.,Shaikh A.S. .2003 .Common weeds of wheat and their control. Pakistan Journal of Water Resources, 7 : 73-76.
Akbar N.,Ehsanullah K.J.,Ali M.A. .2011 .Weed management improves yield and quality of direct seeded rice. Australian Journal of Crop Science, 5 : 688-694.
Ali N.,I. Ullah N.,Akbar N.,Rehman A.,Waseem M.,Ishfaq M.,Hafeez A.,Waheed A. .2019 .Leaf area index, leaf area duration and total dry matter accumulation response of wheat under varying level of nitrogen. International Conference for Sustainable Agriculture, 137 : .
Eyre M.,Critchley C.,Leifert C.,Wilcockson S. .2011 .Crop sequence, crop protection and fertility management effects on weed cover in an organic/conventional farm management trial. European journal of Agronomy, 34 : 153-162.
Gop .2023 .Agriculture in Pakistan Economic Survey, Economic Advisor's Wing, Finance Division. , : 19-23.
Gnanavel I. .2015 .. Weed Control Options for Sustainable Agriculture, 3 : 37-47.
Guerrini L.,Napoli M.,Mancini M.,Masella P.,Cappelli A.,Parenti A.,Orlandini S. .2020 .Wheat grain composition, dough rheology and bread quality as affected by nitrogen and sulfur fertilization and seeding density. Agronomy10:233., : .
Hussain I.,Khan M.A.,Khan H. .2010 .Effect of seed rates on the agro-physiological traits of wheat. Sarhad Journal of Agriculture, 26 : 169-176.
Hussain I.,Khan E.A.,Gul J.,Ozturk M.,Alharby H.,Alamri S. .2017 .Integration of high seeding densities and criss cross row planting pattern suppresses weeds and increases grain yield of spring wheat. Journal of Environmental Biology, 38 : 1139-1145.
Hussain I.,Khan E.A.,Sadozai U.K.,Bakhsh I. .2018 .Metric traits studies in wheat varieties as affected by sowing techniques. Pakistan Journal of Botany, 50 : 1373-1378.
Hussain I.,Malik M.N.,Nadim M.A. .2022 .study on biotic stress in cereals and non-cereals through phytotoxicity caused by Chenopodium album. Pakistan Journal of Weed Science Research, 28 : 405.
Hussain I.,Haq E.,Nazir J. .2023 .climate change scenario favors cultural control of weeds in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) over herbicides application. 1st international conference of climate change and environment. , : 9.
Klein R.N.,Martin A.R.,Lyon D.J.,Extension D.J. .2006 .Institute of Agriculture and Natural Resources. A report Neb Guide G1241, : .
Koolen G.,Rothenberg G. .2019 .Air pollution in Europe. Chemsuschem, 12 : 164-172.
Kolb L.N.,Gallandt E.R.,Molloy T. .2010 .Improving weed management in organic spring barley: physical weed control vs. interspecific competition. Weed Research, 50 : 597-605.
Laghri G.M.,Oad F.C.,Tunia S.,Chacher Q.U.,Gandhi A.W.,Siddiqui M.H.,Hassan A.,Ali A. .2011 .Growth and yield attributes of wheat at different seed rates. Sarhad Journal of Agriculture, 27 : 178-183.
Malik A.U.,Alias M.A.,Bakhsh H.A.,Haji M.A.,Ali M. .2009 .Demonstration and evaluation of effect of weedicides on broad leaved weeds on wheat yield. Journal of Animal and Plant Science, 19 : 193-196.
Marwat K.B.,M. Saeed Z.,Hussain B.,Gull H.,Rashid H. .2008 .Study of various herbicides for weed control in wheat control in wheat under irrigated conditions. Pakistan Journal of Weed Science Research, 14 : 1-8.
Mazhar R.,Ilyas N.,Arshad M.,Khalid A. .2020 .Amelioration potential of biochar for chromium stress in wheat. Pakistan Journal of Botany, 52 : 1159-1168.
Memon S.,Arif H.,Bux M.A.,Sial A.M.,Rahoo W.A.,Maitlo S.M.,Mujataba S.M. .2020 .Variability of some Pakistani commercial wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) varieties for agro-morphological and end-use quality traits. Pakistan Journal of Botany, 5 : 581-592.
Menalled F.D.,Gross K.L.,Hammond M. .2001 .Weed aboveground and seedbank community responses to agricultural management systems. Ecological Applications, 11 : 1586-1601.
Min B.,I. S.J.,Powers P.,Wilde P.R.,Shewry R.P.,Haslam R.P. .2017 .Effects of cultivar and nitrogen nutrition on the lipid composition of wheat flour. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 65 : 5427-5434.
Minolta .2014 .SPAD-502 by Konica Minolta Sensing, inc. , : .
Noshad Q.,Malik N.Z.,Anjum M.,Arif S.,Jahangir S.,Malik Z. .2021 .Screening of salt tolerant wheat varieties under salt stress in region khui rata, District Kotli, (AJK. Pakistan Journal of Botany, 53 : 1177-1182.
Raddy S.R. .2004 .Principle of crop production, growth, regulators and growth analysis. , : .
Sabra F.S.,El-Bakry A.M.,Belal A.E.H.,El-Nabarawy I.M.,Abbassy M.A. .2006 .Effectiveness of herbicides treatments against weeds in maize and their action on yield and yield components. Journal of Pest Count and Environmental Sciences, 14 : 381-390.
Salarzai A. .2001 .effect of different herbicides on weed population and yield of maize (Zea mays L.). Pakistan Journal of Agriculture Sciences, 38 : 1-2.
Sandya N.R.,Singh R. .2018 .Studies on weed dynamics, yield, and economics of short duration pigeonpea (Cajanus cajan L.) as influenced by date of sowing and weed management practices. Excellent Publishers, 7 : 3655-3661.
Singh R.,Dhiman S.E.N.,Rana N.S.,Kumar S.,Singh V.K.,Singh R.G. .2006 .Efficacy of dicamba alone and in combination with isoproturon on wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) and associated weeds. Indian Journal of Agronomy, 51 : 139-141.
Stoskopf N.C. .1981 .Cereals in understanding crop production by Reston company USA. , : 137-139.
Subhan F.,Din N.U.,Azim A.,Shah Z. .2007 .Response of maize crop to various herbicides. Pakistan Journal of Weed Science Research, 13 : 9-15.
UNFPA. .2022 .State of the world population. United Nations Population Fund., : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

59

Views