No Detail Found!

Stability Analysis of Genotype × Environment Interaction for Wheat Genotypes Through Bayesian and Frequentist Approaches

Author(s)
Rabia Munir Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Agriculture,Faisalabad-38040,Pakistan
Muhammad Kashif Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Agriculture,Faisalabad-38040,Pakistan
Muhammad Zafar Iqbal Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Agriculture,Faisalabad-38040,Pakistan
Ghulam Farid Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Agriculture,Faisalabad-38040,Pakistan
Abstract
Genotype-by-Environment Interaction (GEI) is very important for identifying high yielding and stable genotypes in crop performance trails. It is a challenging issue for plant breeders and agronomists to select a better genotype for all locations when these trails are conducted across multiple and unpredictable environments. Mostly, the frequentist approach is used for the analysis of GEI models whereas the Bayesian paradigm has limited application for evaluating these models. The objective of this study is to analyze the GEI model using Bayesian paradigm and compare its efficacy with frequentist approach using multi environment data of wheat. The secondary data on 50 genotypes of wheat sowing under 31 different locations of Punjab, Pakistan has been collected from wheat section of Ayub Agricultural Research Institute. After diagnostic evaluations 33 genotypes and 17 environments has been selected for analysis purpose. The Bayesian and Classical approaches were compared, revealing that the Bayesian Analysis outperformed the Classical approach by providing higher heritability estimates with lower standard errors (SE). Very limited work under Bayesian paradigm is reported in Pakistan. The present study not only provides comprehensive guideline for analyzing GEI models in multi-environment trials but also gives clear guidelines for the comparison of Bayesian and Frequentist approaches in GEI field. Also, the credible intervals for ranks of genotypes has been calculated in this study. The findings indicate that genotype HYT-10047 is the highest yielding and most stable, while NR553 is the lowest yielding genotype.
Publication Details
Page(s) 1013-1021
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences, Volume: 61, Issue: 4, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Heritability, Bayesian approach, genotype by environment interaction, multi-environmental trials., frequentist approach
References
Anuradha T.,Patro A.,Singamsetti Y.S.,Rani U.,Triveni A.N.,Kumari N.,Govanakoppa T.L.,Pathy V.A.,Tonapi V.A. .2022 .Comparative study of AMMI and BLUPbased simultaneous selection for grain yield and stability of finger millet [Eleusine coracana. Frontiers in Plant Science, 12 : 786839.
Aslam M.,Bantan R.A.R.,Khan N. .2021 .Design of tests for mean and variance under complexity-an application to rock measurement data. Measurement, 177 : 109312.
Azevedo C.F.,Barreto C.A.V.,Nascimento M.,Carvalho I.R.,Kehl K.,Cruz C.D.,Nascimento A.C.C. .2023 .Genotype-by-environment interaction of wheat using Bayesian factor analytic models and environmental covariates. Euphytica, 219 : 95.
Bank W. .2020 .Agriculture and Food. Technical Report, : .
Crossa J. .1990 .Statistical analyses of multilocation trials. Advances in Agronomy, Elsevier, 44 : 55-85.
Din A.,Gul R.,Khan H.,Velasco J.G.A.,Persa R.,Sanchez J.Y.,Jarquin D. .2024 .Assessing the Genotypeby-Environment G × E Interaction in Desi Chickpea via the Bayesian Additive Main Effects and Multiplicative Interaction Model. Agriculture, 14 : 215.
Datta G.S.,Hou Y.,Mandal A. .01833 .Credible Distributions of Overall Ranking of Entities. ArXiv Prepr. ArXiv2401, : .
Eberhart S.A.T.,Russell W.A. .1966 .Stability parameters for comparing varieties 1. Crop Science, 6 : 36-40.
Edwards J.W.,Jannink J.L. .2006 .Bayesian modeling of heterogeneous error and genotype × environment interaction variances. Crop Science, 46 : 820-833.
Finlay K.W.,Wilkinson G.N. .1963 .The analysis of adaptation in a plant-breeding programme. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, 14 : 742-754.
Gauch J.H.G. .1988 .Model selection and validation for yield trials with interaction. Biometrics, 44 : 705-715.
Gauch J.H.G. ,Piepho H.P.,Annicchiarico P. .2008 .Statistical analysis of yield trials by AMMI and GGE: Further considerations. Crop Science, 48 : 866-889.
Gelman A. .2004 .Exploratory data analysis for complex models. Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, 13 : 755-779.
Gelman A. .2006 .Prior distributions for variance parameters in hierarchical models (comment on article by Browne and Draper). Bayesian Analysis, 3 : 515-534.
Gollob H.F. .1968 .A statistical model which combines features of factor analytic and analysis of variance techniques. Psychometrika, 33 : 73-115.
Hinkelmann K.,Kempthorne O. .2007 .Introduction to experimental design. , 1 : .
Lee S.Y.,Lee H.S.,Lee C.M.,Ha S.K.,Park H.M.,Lee S.M.,Kwon Y.,Jeung J.U.,Mo Y. .2023 .MultiEnvironment Trials and Stability Analysis for YieldRelated Traits of Commercial Rice Cultivars. Agriculture, 13 : 256.
Lunn D.J.,Best N.,Spiegelhalter D. .2000 .WinBUGS-A Bayesian modelling framework: Concepts, structure, and extensibility. Statistics and Computing, 10 : 325-337.
Olivoto T.,A.D.C. Lucio J.A.G.,Silva B.G.,Sari M.I.,Diel M.I. .2019 .Mean performance and stability in multienvironment trials II: Selection based on multiple traits. Agronomy Journal, 111 : 2961-2969.
Omer S.O.,Abdalla A.W.H.,Mohammed M.H.,M. Singh M.H. .2015 .Bayesian estimation of genotype-by-environment interaction in sorghum variety trials. Communications in Biometry and Crop Science, 10 : 82-95.
Pearce M.,Erosheva E.A. .2024 .Bayesian RankClustering. ArXiv Prepr. ArXiv2406, : .
Perez-Elizalde S.,Jarquin D.,Crossa J. .2012 .A general Bayesian estimation method of linear--bilinear models applied to plant breeding trials with genotype × environment interaction. Journal of Agricultural, Biological and Environmental Statistics, 17 : 15-37.
Raza M.Y.,Wu R.,Lin B. .2023 .A decoupling process of Pakistan's agriculture sector: Insights from energy and economic perspectives. Energy, 263 : 125658.
Salmon S.C. .1951 .Analysis of Variance and Long-time Variety Tests of Wheat 1. Agronomy Journal, 43 : 562-570.
Schuetzenmeister A.,Dufey F. .2022 .VCA: Variance Component Analysis. R package version, 1 : 470.
Shukla G.K. .1972 .Some statistical aspects of partitioning genotype environmental components of variability. Heredity, 29 : 237-245.
Silva C.P.,Oliveira L.A.,Nuvunga J.J.,Pamplona A.K.A.,Balestre M. .2015 .A Bayesian shrinkage approach for AMMI models. Plos One, 10 : 0131414.
Singh M.,Al-Yassin A.,Omer S.O. .2015 .Bayesian estimation of genotypes means, precision, and genetic gain due to selection from routinely used barley trials. Crop Science, 55 : 501-513.
Smith A.B.,Cullis B.R.,Thompson R. .2005 .The analysis of crop cultivar breeding and evaluation trials: an overview of current mixed model approaches. Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 143 : 449-462.
Yan W.,Hunt L.A.,Sheng Q.,Szlavnics Z. .2000 .Cultivar evaluation and mega-environment investigation based on the GGE biplot. Crop Science, 40 : 597-605.
Zubair M.,Akhtar L.H.,Hussain S.,Tariq M.,Mahmood M.R.,Minhas R.,Bukhari M.S.,M.I. Akram M.S.,Ullah R. .2020 .Assessment of genotype by environment interaction (GEI) to determine mega-environment in highly adaptables/stable cultivars of cotton. International Journal of Biology and Biotechnology, 17 : 551-560.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

49

Views