No Detail Found!

Population Dynamics of Sucking Insect Pest and Predator, Chrysoperla carnea in Transgenic Bt Cotton and Non Bt Cotton Varieties

Author(s)
Qadeer Ahmed Soomro Nuclear Institute of Agriculture (NIA),Tandojam-70060, Pakistan
Mubasshir Sohail Nuclear Institute of Agriculture (NIA),Tandojam-70060, Pakistan
Rifat Sultana Department of Zoology, University of Sindh,Jamshoro-76080, Pakistan
Niaz Hussain Khuhro Nuclear Institute of Agriculture (NIA),Tandojam-70060, Pakistan
Raza Muhammad Memon Nuclear Institute of Agriculture (NIA),Tandojam-70060, Pakistan
Abstract
Transgenic Bt cotton, initially introduced to combat bollworm infestations, inadvertently resulted in increased populations of sucking pests such as Thrips tabaci, Bemisia tabaci, and Amerasica devastans in Bt cotton fields. The heavy reliance on indiscriminate pesticide application to control these pests has detrimental effects on natural fauna. This study aimed to explore the efficacy of natural enemies as an alternative to pesticides for managing sucking pests in different varieties of Bt cotton. Field experiments were conducted on various Bt cotton varieties, including Super NIAB-602, Super NIAB-992, Super NIAB-3701, Super NIAB-886, Super NIAB-142, NIABt-102, IR-443, NIA-Bt-100, IR-1513, IRNIBGE- 1524, and the non-transgenic Bt variety Sadori. Population densities of A. devastans, T. tabaci, B. tabaci, and the predator Chrysoperla carnea were recorded on the upper, middle, and lower leaves of twenty plants in each group. Results revealed that Super NIAB-142 exhibited the highest population of A. devastans (10.00±0.57), followed by NIABt (8.00±0.57). Likewise, Super NIAB-602 demonstrated the highest population of T. tabaci (7.66±0.33), with IR-1513 ranking second (6.66±0.88). For B. tabaci, Super NIAB-142 displayed the highest population (10.00±0.57), closely followed by Super NIAB-602 (8.00±1.15). Conversely, Sadori exhibited the lowest populations of A. devastans, T. tabaci, and B. tabaci, with values of 0.33±0.33, 1.00±0.57, and 1.0±0.57, respectively. Additionally, Super NIAB-142 showcased significantly higher populations of C. carnea eggs, larvae, and adults (0.54±0.0, 0.44±0.01, and 0.38±0.05), followed by Super NIAB-602. In contrast, Sadori displayed the lowest populations of C. carnea eggs, larvae, and adults (0.07±0.01, 0.16±0.01, and 0.06±0.06). These findings underscore the potential of utilizing natural enemies, particularly C. carnea, as a viable method for managing sucking pests in transgenic Bt cotton, thereby reducing the excessive dependence on pesticides.
Publication Details
Page(s) 1067-1072
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Zoology, Volume: 57, Issue: 3, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
natural enemies, transgenic, Population fluctuation
References
Aheer G.M.,Ahmed K.J.,Ali A. .1994 .Role of weather in fluctuating aphid density in wheat crop. J. agric. Res., 32 : 295-301.
Ali M.A.,Farooq J.,Batool A.,Zahoor A.,Azeem F.,Mahmood A.,Jabran K. .2019 .Cotton production in Pakistan. K. Jabran and B.S. Chauhan), : 249-276.
Ashfaq M.,Aen M.,Zia K.,Nasreen A.,Hasan A. .2010 .The correlation of abiotic factors and physico-morphic charateristics of (Bacillus thuringiensis) Bt transgenic cotton with whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) and jassid, Amrasca devastans (Homoptera: Jassidae) populations. Afr. J. agric. Res., 5 : 3102-3107.
Badiger H.K.,Patil S.B.,Udikeri S.S.,Chattannavar S.N. .2012 .Comparative eficacy of single (BG I) and stacked Bt cotton hybrids (BG II) under integrated pest management practices. J. Cotton Res. Dev.., 26 : 117-123.
Banerjee S.K. .2002 .Estimation of losses due to major pests of cotton. CICR, Annual Report 2001- 02, : 54-55.
Dhaka S.R.,Pareek B.L. .2007 .Seasonal incidence of natural enemies of key insect pests of cotton and their relationship with weather parameters. J. Pl. Prot. Res., 47 : 418-419.
Dhillon M.K.,Sharma H.C. .2013 .Comparative studies on the efects of Bt-transgenic and nontransgenic cotton on arthropod diversity, seed cotton yield and bollworms control. J. environ. Biol, 34 : 67-73.
Dhillon M.,Pampapathy K.G.,Wadaskar R.M.,Sharma H.C. .2012 .Impact of Bt transgenic cottons and insecticides on target and non- target insect pests, natural enemies and seed cotton yield in India. Indian J. agric. Res., 82 : 248-254.
Eddleston M.,Karalliedde L.,Buckley N.,Fernando R.,G. R. .2002 .Pesticide poisoning in the developing world a minimum pesticides list. Lancet, 6736(02) : 11204-9.
Gatehouse A.M.R.,Gatehouse J.A. .1998 .:AID-PS679>3.0. Pestic. Sci., 52(199802) : 2-7.
Godhani P.H. .2006 .Impact of intercropping on the insect pests suppression in Hybrid cotton-10. D thesis, : .
Hoy M.A.,Nguyen R. .2000 .Classical biological control of brown citrus aphid: Release of Lipolexis scutellaris. , 81 : 24-26.
Jeyakumar P.R.,Tanwar C.K.M.,Singh A.,Monga D.,Bambawale O.M. .2008 .Performance of Bt cotton against sucking pests. J. Biopest., 1 : 223-225.
Konradsen F. .2007 .Acute pesticide poisoning a global public health problem. Danish med. , 54 : 58-59.
Men X.Y.F.,Yardim G.E.,Parajulee M.N. .2005 .Behavior response of Helicoverpa armigera (Lepidoptera: Noctudae) to cotton with and without expression of the CrylAc delta-endotoxin protein of Bacillus thuringiensis Berlinar. J. Ins. Behav, 18 : 33-50.
Men X.Y.,Ge F.,Liu X.H.,Yardim E.N. .2003 .Diversity of arthropod communities in transgenic Bt cotton and non-transgenic cotton agro ecosystems. -32.2.270, 32 : 0046-275.
Michaud S.P. .2001 .Population dynamics of bean aphid (Aphis craccivora Koch) and its predatory coccinellid complex in relation to crop type (Lantil, Lathyrus and Faba bean) and weather conditions. J. entomol. Res., 18 : 25-36.
Naveen A.,Brar D.S.,Butter G.S. .2007 .Evaluation of Bt and non Bt version of two cotton hybrid under diferent spacing against sucking insect pest and natural enemies. J. Cotton Res. Dev., 21 : 106-110.
Ozyigit I.I.,Kahraman M.V.,Ercan O. .2007 .Relation between explants age, total phenols and regeneration response in tissue cultured cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.). Afr. J. Biotech., 6 : 3-8.
Rafee C.M.,Dharwad C.M. .2010 .Insect pest management in desi cotton. Ph.D. thesis, : .
Rekha S.,Nageswararao G.,Dhurera S. .2008 .Efect of legume intercrops on yield and profitability of rain M. fed cotton in vertisols. J. Cotton Res. Dev, 22 : 256-260.
Sagar D.,Patil B.,Bheemanna M. .2011 .Pest status and cry protein content in transgenic cotton. J. Cotton Res. Dev., 25 : 258-262.
Sharma H.C.,Agarwal R.A. .1983 .Role of some chemical components and leaf hairs in varietal resistance in cotton to jassid, Amrasca biguttula biguttula Ishida. J. entomol. Res. Soc., 7 : 145-149.
Solangi B.K.,Talpur M.A.,Nizamani I.A. .2005 .and its predators (Natural enemies) on cotton. J. appl. Sci., 1402 : 1402-1404.
Steel R.G.D.,Torrie J.H.,Dicky D.A. .1997 .Principles and procedures of statistics. A biometrical approach 3rd ed. McGraw-Hill, : .
Udikeri S.S.,Patil B.,Basavanagoud V.K.,Khadi B.M.,Kulkarni K.A.,Vamadevaiah H.M. .2012 .Impact of Bt transgenic cotton on population dynamics of aphids and natural enemies. Indian J. agric. Sci., 82 : 555-560.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

84

Views