Identification of Promising Groundnut Genotypes Using Stability Analysis

Saleem Abid; Muhammad Jahanzaib

doi:10.17582/journal.pjar/2024/37.3.314.319

Author(s)

Saleem Abid National Agricultural Research Centre (NARC),Islamabad,Pakistan

Muhammad Jahanzaib National Agricultural Research Centre (NARC),Islamabad,Pakistan

Abstract

Nine groundnut genotypes were studied for their stability analysis under national uniform yield trials in different agro-climatic zones of Pakistan. The combined variance effects (Anova) based on AMMI model confirmed significant differences (P<0.01) among genotypes, environments, and the genotype by environmental (G x E) interactions. The environmental factors explained 81.29% of the total yield variation. Environment variations proved to be the main factor influencing the performance of groundnutgenotypes in most of the locations where the study was conducted. The initial two components (IPCA1 and IPCA2) clarified 83.2% of the variance because of genotype and GxE interactions. The interaction principal component axis scores of a genotype good indicators of a genotype stability across environments. Various stability methods were used for stable genotypes identification across environments. According to different stability measures groundnut genotype 11AK011 turned out to be the most stable entry as revealed by Wricke’s ecovalence, mean square deviation, coefficient of determination, Shukla’s stability variance and coefficient of variation. The GGE biplot analysis also confirmed that 11AK011 groundnut genotype and can be considered as adaptable to the environments of the experimental sites.

Publication Details

Page(s) 314-319

DOI 10.17582/journal.pjar/2024/37.3.314.319

Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Research, Volume: 37, Issue: 3, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords

AMMI analysis, Environments, GGE, Stability measures, IPCA

References

Abid S.,Zahid S.,Chaudhary M.,Din S.S.,Ali M.A. .2018 .Stability of maize hybrids across environments using GGE biplot and AMMI analysis. Asian J. Agric. Rural Dev., 8, (2) : 188-194.

. .Stability for grain yield in wheat. , : .

. .. , 28 : 61-65.

Ali A.,Masood M.A.,Ashraf Z. .2012 .. , : .

. .Identifying the most promising genotypes in lentil for cultivation in a wide range of environments of Pakistan using various yield stability measures. Pak. J. Bot., 44(6) : 1919-1922.

Ashraf .2016 .Environment Interaction and Stability Analysis in Flax. , : .

Farming Allied,Sci Allied . .. , 5(4) : 278-289.

Baker R.J.,Bakhsh A.,Malik A.Q.,Ghafoor A.,B.A. A. .1988 .Tests for crossover Genotype × Environment interactions. Canadian J. of Plant Sci., 68 : 405-410.

Malik .1995 .Stability of seed yield in chickpea.. , : .

Sci Pak. J. . .. , 47(3-4) : 97-102.

Islam and M.M. Rohman .2010 .Assessment of genotype-by-environment interaction using Additive Main Efects and multiplicative interaction model in Maize Hybrids. Academic J. Plant Sci., 3(4) : 134-139.

Eberhart S.A.,Russell W.A.,Farshadfar E.,Sayed H.S.,Hasan Z. .2012 .Stability parameters for comparing varieties. Crop Sci., 6 : 36-40.

. .. crop sci., 6(3) : 514-524.

Francis T.R,Kannenberg L.W. .1978 .Yield stability studies in short season maize. I. A descriptive method for grouping genotypes. , : .

Sci Can. J. Plant . .. , 58 : 1029-1034.

.2017 .. Government of Pakistan, : .

Hidayatullah S.,Abid N.,Anjum N.,Habib A.,Saeed A. .2017 .Stability Analysis of Tomato Advance Lines across Environments. Science, Technology and Development, 36(3) : 138-141.

Javed H.I.A.,Masood S.,Abid S. .2006 .. , : .

A.K. ,Palta C.,Taner S. .2002 .Additive Main Efects and multiplicative interactions analysis of yield performances in bread Wheat genotypes across environments. Turk J. Agric., 25(2) : 165-172.

. .. , 26 : 275-279.

Sajjad M.,Ishaq M. .2011 .Evaluation of maize hybrids for grain yield Stability in north-west of Pakistan. , 27(2) : 213-218.

Khalil M.A.G. .2013 .Stability Analysis for Promising Yellow Maize Hybrids under Diferent Locations Alex. J. Agric. Res., 58(3) : 279-286.

S. ,Khan J.,Khetran M.A,Hanan A.,Kurd A.A.,Naseer N.S.,S. N.S. . .AMMI and GGE biplot analysis for yield performance and stability assessment of selected Bambara groundnut (Vigna subterranea L. Verdc.) genotypes under the multi-environmental trials (METs). Sci Rep, 22791 : .

Jafar .2014 .Genotypes for Yield under Rain fed Conditions of Highland Balochistan. , : .

Animal Plant,Sci Plant . .. , 24(2) : 521-525.

Kilic H. .2014 .Additive Main Efects and Multiplicative Interactions (AMMI) Analysis of Grain Yield in Barley Genotypes across Environments. J. Agric. Sc., 20 : 337-344.

Mahendran S.,Chandra B.R.,Atlin G. .2006 .AMMI Analysis for stability of grain yield in Rice. Int. J. Bot., 2(2) : 104-106.

M.A. ,Khan M.I.,Mustafa S.Z. .2003 .. , 104 : .

M. ,Ghazanfar H.,Shahbaz M. .2013 .Comparison of diferent methods for evaluating genotypes in National Uniform Wheat Yield Trails in Pakistan. Pak. J. appl. Sci., 385(6) : 385-390.

American-Eurasian J.,Agric J.,Environ J. . .. , 13(9) : 1252-1257.

Nawaz M.S.,Nawaz N.,Yousuf M.,Khan M.A.,Mirza M.Y.,Mohmand A.S.,Sher M.A.,Masood M.A. .2009 .Stability performance for pod yield in groundnut. Pakistan J. Agric., : .

Res. . .. , 22(3-4) : 116-119.

Ngozi A.E.,Uguru M.I.,Obi I.U. .2013 .. , : .

. .Genotypic stability and correlation among quantitative characters in genotypes of aromatic pepper grown over years. African J. Biotechnol, 12(20) : 2792-2801.

Qari M.S.,Khan N.I.,Bajwa M.A. .1990 .. , : .

. .Comparison of wheat cultivars for stability in yield performance. Pak. J. Agric. Res., 11 : 73-77.

Khalil S.M.A.,Shah H.,Ahmad H. .2010 .. , : .

. .Stability analysis of maize hybrids across North West of Pakistan. , 42(2) : 1083-1091.

Ashouri .2011 .Additive Main Efects and multiplicative interactions (AMMI) analysis of dry leaf yield in tobacco hybrids across environments. African J. Biotechnol, 10(21) : 4358-4364.

Sayar M.S.,Anlarsal A.E.,Basbag M. .2013 .. , : .

. .Genotype-environment interactions and stability analysis for dry matter yield and seed yield in Hungarian Vetch. Turk. J. Field Crops, 18(2) : 238-246.

. .Genotype-Environment Interactions and Stability Analysis of Yield and Yield Attributes of Ten Contemporary Wheat Varieties of Pakistan. Sindh Univ. Res. J., 41(1) : 13-24.

Shukla G.K.,Mandefro N.,Habtamu Z. .2008 .87 Solomon A. Heredity, 29 : 237-245.

Genotype-Environment Interaction ,G. .1962 .On a method of understanding the biological diversity in field research. Z PflZücht, 47 : 92-146.