No Detail Found!

Development of Ethical Dilemma Distress Scale for Mental Health Practitioners (EDDS-MHP)

Author(s)
Muqadas Fatima Department of Psychology, University of Central Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan.
Uzma Ilyas Department, Forman Christian College, University, Lahore, Pakistan
Abstract
An ethical dilemma arises when a psychologist encounters a situation where it is unable to find an immediate resolution. In psychotherapy, this situation can act as an "ethical canary," similar to a canary in a mineshaft serving as an early sign of trouble. This study aimed to create a scale for measuring the ethical dilemma distress that is experienced by mental health practitioners when dealing with ethical dilemmas in their practice. The study was conducted in three phases: Phase I involved generating items, followed by Phase II, which encompassed constructing the scale, and in Phase III, the scale underwent reliability and validity analysis. Expert review was sought from 8 experts on 75 items developed in the item generation stage. The assumptions for factor analysis were satisfied as KMO and Bartlett's test of sphericity were significant and significant correlations were found within the items. An exploratory factor analysis (EFA) with principal component analysis (PCA) was conducted on 27 items, employing Promax rotation. EFA suggested the retention of four factors, which included ethical distress in clinical practice, ethical quandaries concerning professional boundaries, ethical disclosure dilemmas, and conflicts of values leading to distress. The Ethical Dilemma Distress Scale for Mental Health Practitioners (EDDSMHP) was thus found to be a reliable and valid tool for the assessment of ethical dilemma distress among mental health practitioners. The instrument developed can be a crucial step in timely and accurately assessing ethical dilemma distress among mental health practitioners. It may also help to develop a tailored ethical training program as well as design interventions to inculcate ethical decision-making skills.
Publication Details
Page(s) 613-637
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Psychological Research, Volume: 39, Issue: 3, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Exploratory factor analysis, Ethics, psychotherapy, scale development, Distress, ethical dilemma, mental health practitioner
References
Ahmad S. S.,Koncsol S. W. .2022 .Cultural factors influencing mental health stigma: Perceptions of mental illness (POMI) in Pakistani emerging adults. Religions, 13(5) : .
Ajoudani F.,Baghaei R.,Lotfi M. .2018 .Moral distress and burnout in Iranian nurses: The mediating effect of workplace bullying. Nursing Ethics, 26 : 1834-1847.
Amaglo E. .2022 .Managing boundaries and multiple relationships in counselling and psychotherapy. Global Journal of Psychology, 2(1) : 361-11.
American Counseling Association. .2006 .ACA code of ethics. Journal of Counseling and Development, 84(2) : 6678.
American Psychological Association. .2017 .Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct. , : .
Ascherman L. I.,Rubin S. .2007 .Current ethical issues in child and adolescent psychotherapy. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 07(1) : 21-35.
Bakri K. I.,Mustaffa M. S. .2013 .Spiritual approach with a Muslim female student dealing with adultery case. International Journal of Fundamental Psychology and Social Sciences (IJSS), 3(4) : 59-62.
Barnett J. E. .2019 .The ethical practice of psychotherapy: Clearly within our reach. Psychotherapy, 56(4) : 431-440.
Bonnie R. J.,Zelle H.,Mastroianni J. P.,Kahn J. P. .2019 .Ethics in mental health care: A public health perspective. The Oxford handbook of public health ethics, : 204-218.
Borenstein J. .2020 .org/patients-families/st igma-and-discrimination. , : .
Brabender V. .2019 .. , : .
Bhasin S. K.,Bharadwaj I. U.,Beniwal R. P.,Gupta V.,Bhatia T.,Deshpande S. N. .2021 .Ethical dilemmas encountered in suicide research and management: Experiences of young mental health professionals. Indian Journal of Medical Ethics, 7(2) : 93-102.
Colnerud C.,Hansson B.,Salling B.,Tikkanen T. .1996 .Ethical dilemmas of psychologists: Finland and Sweden. International Journal of Psychology, 31(3-4) : 5726-5726.
Conlon D.,Raeburn T.,Wand T. .2019 .Disclosure of confidential information by mental health nurses, of patients they assess to be a risk of harm to self or others: An integrative review. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 28(6) : 1235-1247.
Corley M. C.,Elswick R. K.,Gorman M.,Clor T. .2001 .Development and evaluation of a moral distress scale. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 33(2) : 250-256.
Corley M. C. .2002 .Nurse moral distress: A proposed theory and research agenda. Nursing Ethics, 9(6) : 636-650.
Cristea I. A.,Ioannidis J. P. A. .2018 .Improving disclosure of financial conflicts of interest for research on psychosocial interventions. JAMA Psychiatry, 75(6) : .
Dasti R.,Farhan R.,Naqvi Fatima,Sitwat T.,Zehra Bokharey A.,I. A. .2020 .Ethical and Moral Dilemmas in Psychotherapy. In advances in religious and cultural studies (ARCS) book series. , : ch013-258.
Deng J.,Qian M.,Gan Y.,Hu S.,Gao J.,Huang Z.,Zhang L. .2014 .Emerging practices of counseling and psychotherapy in China: Ethical dilemmas in dual relationships. Ethics and Behavior, 26(1) : 63-86.
Ekberg S.,Barnes R. K.,Kessler D. S.,Malpass A.,Shaw A. R. G. .2016 .Managing clients‟ expectations at the outset of online Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) for depression. Health Expectations: An International Journal of Public Participation in Health Care and Health Policy, 19(3) : 557-569.
Elzamzamy K.,Keshavarzi H. .2019 .Navigating Ethical Dilemmas in Mental Health Practice Between Professional Ethics and Islamic Values. Journal of Islamic Faith and Practice, : .
Eniola K. .2018 .Is it ethical to accept gifts from patients. PubMed, 25(1) : 40-40.
Fatima M.,Ilyas U. .2023 .) creating a better world for future held. 2nd international conference on applied psychology (ICAP-, : .
Field A. .2015 .Discovering statistics using IBM SPSS statistics. , : .
Fumis R. R. L.,Amarante G. A. J.,Nascimento G. A. J.,Junior J. M. V. .2017 .Moral distress and its contribution to the development of burnout syndrome among critical care providers. Annals of Intensive Care, 7(1) : .
Gerger H.,Nascimento A. F.,Locher C.,Gaab J.,Trachsel M. .2020 .What are the Key Characteristics of a “Good” Psychotherapy? Calling for Ethical Patient Involvement. , 11 : 406.
Gupta A.,Mishra P.,Pandey C.,Singh U.,Sahu C.,Keshri A. .2019 .Descriptive statistics and normality tests for statistical data. Annals of Cardiac Anaesthesia, 22(1) : 67-72.
Hamdani S. U.,Huma Z. E.,Tamizuddin-Nizami A. .2021 .Debate: Child and adolescent mental health services in Pakistan; Do we need inpatient mental health facilities for children and young people?. Child and adolescent mental health, 26(2) : 182-183.
Hem M. H.,Molewijk B.,Weimand B.,Pedersen R. .2022 .Patients with severe mental illness and the ethical challenges related to confidentiality during family involvement: A scoping review. Frontiers in Public Health, 10 : .
Hill B. D. .2011 .The sequential Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin procedure as an alternative for determining the number of factors in common-factor analysis: A Monte Carlo simulation. , : .
Hinkins T. R. .1998 .A Brief Tutorial on the development of measures for use in survey questionnaires. Organizational Research Methods, 1 : 104-121.
Jackson A.,Hansen J.,Cook-Ly J. .2013 .. Value Conflicts in Psychotherapy. Issues in Religion and Psychotherapy, 35(1) : .
Jackson M. K.,Burns K. K.,Richter M. S. .2014 .Confidentiality and treatment decisions of minor clients: A health professional‟s dilemma and policy makers challenge. Springer Plus, 3 : 193-1801.
Jain S.,Kuppili P. P.,Pattanayak R. D.,Sagar R. .2017 .Ethics in psychiatric research: Issues and recommendations. Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine, 39(5) : 558-565.
Jameton A. .1985 .Nursing practice, the ethical issues. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 22(85) : 90057-4.
Jameton A. .2013 .A reflection on moral distress in nursing together with a current application of the concept. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry, 10(3) : 297-308.
Javed M.,Abbas Q.,Husssain S. .2021 .Low literacy rate at primary level: Identification of causes and impacts. 2021(5-II)39, 5(2) : 492-506.
Johnson L.,Federman E. J. .2014 .Training, experience, and attitudes of VA psychologists regarding LGBT issues: Relation to practice and competence. Psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity, 1(1) : 10-18.
Kok N.,Gurp J.,Hoeven J.,Fuchs M.,Hoedemaekers C.,Zegers M. .2021 .Complex interplay between moral distress and other risk factors of burnout in ICU professionals: Findings from a cross-sectional survey study. -012239, 32(4) : 225-234.
Lee S. M.,Baker C. R.,Cho S. H.,Heckathorn D. E.,Newgent M. W.,Ogle R. A.,Powell N. T.,Quinn M. L.,Wallace J. J.,Yu S. L.,K. S. L. .2007 .Development and Initial psychometrics of the Counselor Burnout Inventory. Measurement and Evaluation in Counseling and Development, 40(3) : 142-154.
Lewandowski A.,Fronapfel B.,Spector J.,Szczepkowski K.,Davidson S. .2021 .Ethical Considerations in Psychological Consultation to Critical Care Settings. , : 313-344.
Lindén E.,Rådeström J. .2008 .Ethical dilemmas among psychologists in Sweden and South Africa [Unpublished master dissertation]. pid=di va2% 3A117336&dswid=-7219, : .
McDonald-Sardi J.,Mathews R.,Reece J.,Pratt C. .2020 .The effect of experience in psychological practice on making ethical judgements. Australian Psychologist, 55(6) : 634-644.
Mahmood S. R. S.,Abdallah S. S. .2019 .(pp. 2nd International Seminar on Guidance and Counseling, : 143-149.
Metselaar S.,Widdershoven G. .2019 .Moral dilemmas in (not) treating patients who feel they are a burden. Bioethics, 33(4) : 431-438.
Morrison S. N.,Sigman L. .2021 .Consent, refusal of care, and shared decision-making for pediatric patients in emergency settings. Pediatric Emergency Medicine Practice, 18(5) : 1-20.
Mubashir A.,Batool S. S.,Arafat S. M. Y. .2023 .Psychometric evaluation and validation of Urdu social rank scale for women with infertility in Pakistan. , 14 : 1150941.
Murphy D.,Irfan N.,Barnett H.,Castledine E.,Enescu L. .2018 .A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative research into mandatory personal psychotherapy during training. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 18(2) : 199-214.
Naz B.,Batool S. S.,Fida M. K.,Khan M. Z. .2022 .Construction and validation of Emotional and Social Distress Scale for men and women diagnosed with infertility: Further evidence of its construct validity and psychometric properties. , 14(3) : 147-157.
Nezu A. M. .2020 .. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 05(4) : 417-425.
Nicolini M. E.,Kim S. Y. H.,Churchill M. E.,Gastmans C. .2020 .Should euthanasia and assisted suicide for psychiatric disorders be permitted? A systematic review of reasons. Psychological Medicine, 50(8) : 1-16.
Pallant J. .2010 .SPSS survival manual (4th ed). McGraw Hill., : .
Prytz M.,Harkestad K. N.,Veseth M.,Bjornestad J. .2019 .“It‟s not a life of war and conflict”: Experienced therapists‟ views on negotiating a therapeutic alliance in involuntary treatment. Annals of General Psychiatry, 18 : 1-10.
Rathert C.,May D. R.,Chung H. S. .2015 .Nurse moral distress: A survey identifying predictors and potential interventions. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 10 : 39-49.
Ringstad R. .2008 .The ethics of dual relationships: Beliefs and behaviors of clinical practitioners. Families in Society, 89(1) : 69-77.
Rosser G. .2018 .Religion and culture. , : .
Różyńska J. .2022 .The ethical anatomy of payment for research participants. Health Care and Philosophy, 25(3) : 449-464.
Sahar N. E.,Hussain S.,Noshili A. I.,Shahbal S.,Hamdi A. M.,Khan A.,Hakami H. Y.,Alsaed A. M. S.,Alotaibi A.,Alharbi A. A.,Almutairy A. M.,Albeshri M. H.,Nouh N.,Alshakarah N. F.,Haloash T. A. .2022 .A comparative account on ethical considerations in practice of clinical psychology. Clinical Schizophrenia and Related Psychoses, 16(2) : 1-4.
Sikora M.,Mazurek M.,Kopański Z.,Chajneta M.,Sokolnyk S. .2019 .Professional ethical dilemmas of nurses in terms of care palliative. Journal of Public Health, Nursing and Medical Rescue, 3 : 32-15.
Somerville M. .2001 .The ethical canary. Penguin Global., : .
Tabachnick B. G.,Fidell L.S. .2001 .Using multivariate statistics (5th ed. Allyn and Bacon., : .
Trachsel M.,Biller-Andorno N. .2019 .Informed consent for psychotherapy includes much more than the setting. Swiss Medical Weekly, 149 : .
Trachsel M.,Holtforth M. G. .2019 .How to strengthen patients‟ meaning response by an ethical informed consent in psychotherapy. , 10 : .
Wagner W. E. .2020 .Using IBM SPSS statistics for research methods and social science statistics. Sage Publications, : .
Watkins M. W. .2006 .Determining parallel analysis criteria. Journal of Modern Applied Statistical Methods, 5(2) : 344-346.
Wilde S. V. .2021 .context=etd&httpsredir= 1&referer=. , : .
Williams R. .2016 .Measurement error 2: Scale construction (very brief overview). , 31 : .
Winterberg C. A.,Brummel B. J.,Ayres T. B.,Kerr A. J. .2021 .Applying ethical dilemmas to professional ethics training and education: Practical implications and future directions. Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 14(3) : 325-330.
Wolfson E. .2019 .The fee in social work: Ethical dilemmas for practitioners. org/paper/28 eb27679c770bebda27e3744101e97d602fa2b4, 44(3) : 269-273.
Wu Y. .2022 .Editorial: Qualitative research on therapist-client interaction in psychotherapy. , 13 : .
Zaman S.,Naqvi I. .2022 .Development and validation of a Perceived Gender Discrimination Scale (PGDS) for Pakistani women. Foundation University Journal of Psychology, 6(1) : .
0

Citations

3

Downloads

56

Views