No Detail Found!

Comparative analysis of scalpel versus diathermy incisions in midline laparotomy

Author(s)
Shahab ul Huddah Department of General Surgery, Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences,Islamabad,Pakistan
Shahzad Hussain Waqar Department of General Surgery, Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences,Islamabad,Pakistan
Isbah Rashid Department of General Surgery, Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences,Islamabad,Pakistan
Abstract
Objective: To compare diathermy versus scalpel incisions for midline laparotomy in terms of mean blood loss, mean incision related time, frequency of postoperative wound infection, and mean postoperative pain. Methodology: This randomized clinical trial was carried out at Department of General Surgery at Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, Islamabad and included 176 patients who underwent midline laparotomy. Patients were randomized to two groups; those who received incision with diathermy were placed in group A, and those who received incision with scalpel in group B. Variables analyzed were mean blood loss, mean incision related time, frequency of postoperative wound infection, and mean postoperative pain. Results: Each group had 88 patients with mean age was 39.8 ± 12.4 years and 41.9 ± 10.5 years in group A and B, respectively. Majority of the patients in both groups were male. Postoperative infection was comparable in both groups. Mean incision related time in group A was 6.3 ± 0.9 seconds and 7.2 ± 2.1 seconds in group B (p < 0.001). Mean blood loss in group A was 1.3 ± 0.3 mL and in group B 1.4 ± 0.3 mL (p = 0.006). Mean pain score was significantly lesser in group A than group B. There was no statistically significant difference in postoperative wound infection in short term post operatively. Conclusion: Diathermy incision is a safe and expedient technique as it takes lesser time, lesser blood loss and reduced postoperative pain as compared to scalpel. Diathermy should be used an alternative method for incision in midline laparotomy.
Publication Details
Page(s) 111-114
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Rawal Medical Journal, Volume: 48, Issue: 1, Year: 2023

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Laparotomy, scalpel., Diathermy incision
References
Siraj A,Gilani AAS,Dar MF,Raziq S. .2011 .Elective midline laparotomy; comparison of diathermy and scalpel incisions. Professional Med J, 18 : 106-11.
Saeed S,Ali A,Zainab S,Khan MTJ .2017 .Scalpel versus diathermy of midline skin incisions: Comparison of mean pain scores on second postoperative day. J Pak Med Assoc, 67 : 1502-5.
Ali Q,Siddique K,Mirza S,Malik AZ .2009 .Comparison of superficial surgical site infection following use of diathermy and scalpel for, 'making skin incision in inguinal hernioplasty. Niger J Clin Pract, 12 : 371-4.
Ragesh KV,Siddarth M. .2017 .Outcome of skin incision by cautery versus steel scalpel in hernia surgery: a prospective cohort study at a tertiary medical college hospital in. South India Int Surg J, 4 : 1521-4.
Jamali KS,Khan NA,Jawed M,Shaikh U .2015 .Diathermy incisions v/s surgical scalpel incisions; outcome in general surgery. Professional Med J, 22 : 1520-4.
Ahmad NZ,Ahmed A .2011 .Meta-analysis of the effectiveness of surgical scalpel or diathermy in making abdominal skin incisions. Ann Surg, 253 : 8-13.
Talpur AA,Khaskheli AB,Kella N,Jamal A .2015 .Randomized, clinical trial on diathermy and scalpel incisions in elective general surgery. Iran Red Crescent Med J, 17 : e14078.
Ayandipo OO,Afuwape OO,Irabor D,Oluwatosin OM,Odigie V .2015 .Diathermy versus scalpel incision in a heterogeneous cohort of general surgery patients in a Nigerian Teaching Hospital. Niger J Surg, 21 : 43-7.
Elbohoty AE,Gomaa MF,Abdelaleim M,Abd-ElGawad M,Elmarakby M. .2015 .Diathermy versus scalpel in transverse abdominal incision in women undergoing repeated cesarean section: A randomized controlled trial. J Obstet Gynaecol Res, 41 : 1541-6.
Chrysos E,Athanasakis E,Xynos E,Zoras O. .2005 .A prospective study comparing diathermy and scalpel incisions in tension-free inguinal hernioplasty. Am Surg, 71 : 326-9.
Ali MA .2014 .Diathermy versus scalpel incisions for open cholecystectomy: A comparative study. Pak Armed Forces Med J, 64 : 56-60.
Chalya PL,Mchembe MD,Mabula JB,Gilyoma JM .2013 .Diathermy versus Scalpel incision in elective midline laparotomy: A prospective randomized controlled clinical study. East Centr Afr J Surg, 18 : 71-7.
Prakash LD,Balaji N,Kumar SS,Kate V .2015 .Comparison of electrocautery incision with scalpel incision in midline abdominal surgery - a double blind randomized controlled trial. Int J Surg, 19 : 78-82.
Mukerjee MP,Patole M. .2019 .Scalpel versus diathermy skin incision: a randomized clinical trial. Int Surg J, 7 : 258.
Ly J,Mittal A,Windsor J .2012 .Systematic review and metaanalysis of cutting diathermy versus scalpel for skin incision. Br J Surg, 99 : 613-20.
Franchi M,Ghezzi F,Benedetti-Panici PL,Melpignano M. .2001 .A multicenter collaborative study on the use of cold scalpel and electro cautery for midline abdominal incision. Am J Surg, 181 : 128-32.
Pandey S,Choubey RP,Narain IT .2019 .Diathermy versus conventional scalpel in making an abdominal incision: a prospective study. J Clin Diag Res, 13 : 9-11.
Stupart DA,Sim FW,Chan ZH,Guest GD,Watters DA .2016 .Cautery versus scalpel for abdominal skin incisions: a double blind, randomized crossover trial of scar cosmesis. ANZ J Surg, 86 : 303-6.
Agar E,Karakoc G .2021 .Comparison of electrocautery and scalpel for blood loss and postoperative pain in Pfannenstiel incisions in recurrent cesarean sections: a randomized controlled trial. Clin Exp Obstet Gynecol, 48 : 534-9.
Meka PN,Khullar P,Anand VJ .2004 .To compare the superiority of electrocautery over the traditional scalpel for skin incisions. J Surg Res, 121 : 339-41.
Groot G,Chappell EW .1994 .Electrocautery used to create incisions does not increase wound infection rates. Am J Surg, 167 : 601-3.
Nandurkar VS,Mohan-Kumar K,Prakash M.,Suma S. .2018 .Diathermy versus scalpel incisions in elective abdominal surgery: a comparative study. Int Surg J, 5 : 3124-8.
Farooque U,Ahmed R,Kumar D .2019 .Mean post-operative pain score in midline laparotomy incisions made using scalpel vs monopolar diathermy. J Liaquat Uni Med Health Sci, 18 : 99-103.
Okereke CE,Katung AI,Adesunkanmi AK,Alatise OI .2019 .Surgical outcome of cutting diathermy versus scalpel skin incisions in uncomplicated appendectomy: A comparative study. Niger Postgrad Med J, 26 : 100-5.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

119

Views