No Detail Found!

Multiple choice questions as a single tool for assessing retention of knowledge in problem-based learning

Author(s)
Imrana Khan Department of Biochemistry, Dow Medical College, Karachi, Pakistan
Aslam Fareed Department of Marketing, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan.
Abstract
To test if traditional multiple-choice-questions (MCQ) can be used in evaluating the retention of knowledge by two methods, problem-based learning (PBL) and lecture-based learning (LBL). Design: An observational study. Place and Duration of Study: The study was conducted at the Dow Medical College over a period of eight months. Subjects and Methods: All 249 second year medical students attending classes were included and taught a topic of biochemistry by the LBL method. Among these students 141 were then taught another topic of biochemistry by a PBL method. A traditional MCQ test was conducted at the conclusion of each topic. Five months later, they were given a specially-designed questionnaire to find their own retention of knowledge by each method. The same two MCQ tests were repeated. Students' self-assessment was compared for both the methods by the Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test for matched samples. Paired t-test for mean MCQ scores was done to compare their scores at 0 and 5 months. Results: No significant difference was found between their mean scores at 0 months by the PBL or LBL methods but after five months, the retest score showed that the material taught by LBL was retained more (though not significantly) than that taught by PBL, although by the students’ own assessment, retention by PBL was thought to be significantly higher than by LBL (p = 0.001). Conclusion: There was a discrepancy between the students’ self-assessment of retention of knowledge and that elicited by the traditional MCQs. Thus, traditional MCQs cannot be used as a sole evaluation tool for retention of knowledge by PBL.
Publication Details
Page(s) 494-496
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Journal of College of Physicians and Surgeons--Pakistan : JCPSP, Volume: 11, Issue: 8, Year: 2001

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Problem-based learning. Retention of Knowledge. Biochemistry. Multiple-choice-questions
References
. .Effectivenessof problem-baseldearning curricular:esearcahnd theory. AcadMedZWd, 75(3) : 259-66.
.1990 .Problem-based learning:cognitive retentionand cohorttraitsof randomlyselectepdarticipantasnd declinersA. cadMed, 65(9) : S11-12.
.1993 .Problem-baseldearning: a reviewof literatuorneitsoutcomesand implement­a tionissues. AcadMed, 68 : 52-81.
OttL .1992 .An introductiontostatisticamlethodsand data analysis. , : 192-4.
David TJ .1975 .Context-dependenmtemory learningasan alternatitvoelecture-basceodntinuing in twonaturaelnvironmentso:n landand underwater. BeJPsychol, 66 : 325-31.
David TJ .1996 .. edEduc, 30 : 357-63.
. .Foundationsof problem-baseldearning: someexplanatornyotes. , 27 : 422-32.
.1973 .A studyof retentioonf knowledge of neurosciencesinformation. JMed Educ, 48 : 867-9.
. .Problem-baseldearning-timteo move. , : .
Newbie DI .1999 .lecture-baseldearningin a courseof basicpharmacology: a controllerda,ndomizedstudy. MedEduc, 33 : 106-13.
Kaufman DM .2000 .Problem-baseldearning-timteo step back. MedEduc, 34 : 510-11.
.1998 .eta! Comparisonof problem-baseldearninagnd lecturfeorma tin continuing medicaleducationon headachediagnosis. ed Educ, 32 : 590-6.
Blake RL . .Studentperfo­r mances on Step1 and Step 2 of theUnited States. , : .
.2000 .A conceptualframework to guide the developmentof self-directed, lifelonglearnin gin problem-basemdedicalcurricula. MedEduc, 34 : 299-306.
FrostM .1996 .An analysisof the scope and valueof problem-baseldearningin the educationof healt­h careprofessionalsJA. dvNurs, 24 : 1047-53.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

74

Views