No Detail Found!

Exploring the Experiences of Undergraduate Medical Students with Online Open-Book Exams: An Exploratory Qualitative Study

Author(s)
KHAULAH JAWED Dental education department, Avicenna dental college Lahore, Pakistan
TAHIRA SADIQ Department of Community Medicine, RILM, Pakistan
AZHAR RASHID Riphah International University,Islamabad,Pakistan
REHAN AHMED KHAN Department of Surgery Riphah International University, Islamabad, Pakistan
RAHEELA YASMIN Department of medical Education, Riphah International University, Islamabad, Pakistan
Abstract
During COVID-19 medical education system in our ever-burgeoning societies thus saw a paradigm shift from inperson interactions to a virtual ones. In Pakistan, HEC also preferred online open-book exams (OBE) to closed-book exams (CBE) as an assessment strategy; issued guidelines accordingly. The absorption of this new assessment strategy proved daunting for undergraduate (UG) medical students. Careful understanding of their experiences proffers a seamless integration of online OBE in online assessment as a whole. Methods: The Qualitative exploratory design has been utilized. The sampling technique includes purposeful sampling with maximum variation in sampling type. The sample size was eighteen students for three FGDs (six students in each group). Online FGDs were conducted and thematic analysis was done with verbatim transcription of data. Result: Eight themes have been extracted from the data. The themes include understanding of students with online OBE, practice and training for online OBE, preparation for students for OBE, attempting online OBE, the spectrum of emotions, educational impact and benefits of online OBE, difficulties encountered during online OBE, and anticipated future of OBE in medical education. Conclusion: Experiences of UG medical students in online OBE indicate its potential in future applications, such as formative assessment, teaching strategy, complementing conventional exams, and assessing real-life workplace situations. Relevant findings have enabled the furnishing of one model for the effective utilization of online OBE for institutions and students.
Publication Details
Page(s) 131-136
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Medical and Health Sciences, Volume: 16, Issue: 05, Year: 2022

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Synchronous, undergraduate medical education, problemsolving, Online Open-book exams, application of knowledge
References
Masood J. Technology Enhanced RA K .2020 .Assessment (TEA) in COVID 19 Pandemic. , 36(COVID19) : 3.
Comparing .2016 .-book and closed-book examinations: A systematic review. Acad Med, 91(4) : 583-99.
Giordano L,Cipollaro L,Migliorini F,Maffulli N. .2020 .Impact of Covid-19 on Undergraduate and Residency Training. , 19(5) : 199-206.
Available ,Fatima SS,Idrees R,Jabeen K,Sabzwari S,Khan S. .2021 .Online assessment in undergraduate medical education: Challenges and solutions from a LMIC university. Pakistan J Med Sci, 37(4) : 945-51.
.2020 .(6):1-8. On U. HEC Policy Guidance Series on COVID-19, : .
Farooq F,Rathore FA,Mansoor SN . .Challenges of online medical education in Pakistan during COVID-19 pandemic. J Coll Physicians Surg Pakistan., : .
.2020 .. , 30(1) : S67-9.
Damania T,Sharma S,Joegi A . .Remote online open book exams - students' 18.. , : .
Teach view. Clin .2020 .. , : 1-2.
Jervis CG,Brown LR . .The prospects of sitting 'end of year' open book exams in the light of COVID-19: A medical student's perspective. , : .
Zagury-Orly I,Durning SJ,Michael K,Lyden E,Custer T.,Open-Book Examinations T. .2020 .OBEs) in an Ultrasound Physics Course: A Good Idea or a Bad Experiment? J Diagnostic Med Sonogr. Med Teach [Internet], 0(0) : 1-2.
Bengtsson L .2019 .Take-home exams in higher education: A systematic review. Educ Sci, 9(4) : .
Er HM,Nadarajah VD,Wong PS,Mitra NK .2020 .Practical Considerations for Online Open Book Examinations in Remote Settings. MedEdPublish, 9(1) : 1-7.
Prasad K,Education RA-J of E,Yudkowsky R .2009 .4. , : .
.2009 .. Merriam S. Basic Qualitative Research, 12 : .
Rendle KA,Abramson CM,Garrett SB,Halley MC,Dohan D. .2019 .Beyond exploratory: A tailored framework for designing and assessing qualitative health research. BMJ Open, 9(8) : .
W.CressWell J. EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH. Edition F. Paul A.,Smith F. Paul A.,Christina Robb KM .2016 .. , : 1.
Castleberry A,Nolen A .2018 .Thematic analysis of qualitative research data: Is it as easy as it sounds? Curr Pharm Teach Learn. , 10(6) : 807-15.
Available ,Nowell LS,Norris JM,White DE,Moules NJ .2017 .Thematic Analysis: Striving to Meet the Trustworthiness Criteria. Int J Qual Methods, 16(1) : 1-13.
Fourth. Sons JW .2016 .. , : 1.
Karagiannopoulou E.,Entwistle N. .2013 .Influences on personal understanding : Intentions , approaches to learning , perceptions of assessment , and a ' meeting of minds '. Psycology Teach Rev, 19(2) : 80-96.
Karagiannopoulou E,Milienos FS .2013 .Exploring the relationship between experienced students' preference for open- and closed-book examinations, approaches to learning and achievement. Educ Res Eval, 19(4) : 271-96.
Swart AJ,Sutherland T. . .Student perspectives of open book versus closed book 27.. , : .
Green ST,Ferrante SG,Heppard CJ,Teach Motivation. J Eff .2016 .Using Open-Book Exams to Enhance Student Learning, Performance, and. , 16(1) : 19-35.
Westerkamp AC,Heijne-Penninga M,Kuks JBM,Cohen-Schotanus J .2013 .Open-book tests: Search behaviour, time used and test scores. Med Teach, 35(4) : 330-2.
Dale VHM,Wieland B,Pirkelbauer B,Nevel A .2009 .Value and benefits of open-book examinations as assessment for deep learning in a post-graduate animal health course. J Vet Med Educ, 36(4) : 403-10.
Anaya L,Evangelopoulos N,Lawani U. AC .2010 .. , 2137 : .
CLOSED-BOOK TESTING .2010 .: AN Open-Book vs . Closed-Book Testing : an Experimental Comparison. Am Soceity Eng Educ, 11 : .
du Preez H .2012 .Taxation students' perceptions of open-book assessment prior to the qualifying examination of South African chartered accountants. South African J Account Res, 26(1) : 119-42.
Du Preez H. Taxation .2015 .students' perceptions of open-book assessment: a follow-up interactive qualitative analysis. South African J Account Res, 29(1) : 84-99.
Al-kilidar H,Sixsmith A,Leveaux R .2018 .(2).. Aust Assoc Eng Educ confrence Proc, : .
Heijne-Penninga M,Kuks JBM,Hofman WHA,Muijtjens AMM,Cohen-Schotanus J .2013 .Influence of PBL with open-book tests on knowledge retention measured with progress tests. Adv Heal Sci Educ, 18(3) : 485-95.
Myyry L,Joutsenvirta T .2015 .Open-book, open-web online examinations: Developing examination practices to support university students' learning and self-efficacy. Act Learn High Educ, 16(2) : 119-32.
Educ Psychol Contemp .2002 .. , 27(2) : 270-95.
Johanns B,Dinkens A,Moore J.,Minder SP,Weibel D,Wissmath B,Schmitz FM .2017 .Do students achieve the desired learning goals using open-book formative assessments?. Int J Med Educ., 08 : 89-94.
Heijne-Penninga M,Kuks JBM,Hofman WHA,Cohen-Schotanus J .2011 .Directing students to profound open-book test preparation: The relationship between deep learning and open-book test time. Med Teach, 33(1) : 16-21.
Heijne-Penninga ,Kuks JBM,Schönrock-Adema J,Snijders TAB .2008 .Open-book tests to complement assessment-programmes: Analysis of open and closed-book tests. Adv Heal Sci Educ, 13(3) : 263-73.
JR. Online Stowell .2015 .. , 1(1) : 7-13.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

95

Views