No Detail Found!

Establishing the Needs Assessment for Improving Dietary Assessment for Pakistani Population Evidence from Qualitative Study Findings

Author(s)
AFIFA TANWEER College of Home Economics, University of the Punjab Lahore,Pakistan
MEHWISH NIAZ University of Management and Technology,Lahore,Pakistan
SAMRA IMRAN Queen Mary Graduate College,Lahore,Pakistan
AYESHA HUMAYUN Shaikh Zayed Medical Complex,Lahore,Pakistan
ZAIB-UN-NISA HUSSAIN Institute of Chemistry, University of the Punjab,Lahore,Pakistan
Abstract
Dietary assessment is one of the four major components of direct nutritional assessment. Several tools have been established for assessing the dietary intake of individuals as well as the communities. However, dietary intake is a complex exposure variable which is difficult to measure accurately. This study was conducted for needs assessment and suggestions of local dietary assessment tool users (clinical dietitians and researchers) regarding improvements in these tools. Methods: Semi structured interviews were used to conduct this study. A total of ten participants selected using purposive sampling technique were interviewed after which data saturation was reached. The analysis was performed through transcription, meaning condensation, and then establishing data driven themes and patterns. The data thus obtained was represented in tabular and narrative format. Results: Each interview took 45 minutes on average. Twenty Four Hour Recall (24HR) was the most commonly used tool of dietary assessment recorded in 13 out of 14 responses (92.8%) followed by Food Frequency Questionnaire (FFQ) recorded in 10 out of 14 responses (71.4%). A total of six themes emerged for the gaps associated with the use of dietary assessment tools as perceived by interview respondents. Conclusion: Interview data collected from local nutrition and dietetic experts regarding perceived problems in dietary assessment showed that the dietary intake data can be subject to information bias which affects the overall quality of data set. There is a need to acknowledge these errors and find out localized solutions to reduce these errors for improving data quality.
Publication Details
Page(s) 1123-1125
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Medical and Health Sciences, Volume: 16, Issue: 03, Year: 2022

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Dietary Assessment, nutritional status assessment, qualitative interviews, information bias
References
Fagúndez L. J. M.,Torres A. R.,Sánchez M. E. G.,Rodrigo M. L.,Rocamora C. P.,J. A. I. C. P. .2015 .Diet history: Method and applications. Nutricion hospitalaria, 31(3) : 57-61.
.2018 .Dietary Assessment- A resource guide to method selection and application in low resource settings Rome.. , : .
Foster E.,Bradley J. .2018 .Methodological considerations and future insights for 24-hour dietary recall assessment in children. Nutrition Research, 51 : 1-11.
Heikkilä L.,Vanhala M.,Korpelainen R.,Tossavainen P. .2021 .Agreement between an Image-Based Dietary Assessment Method and a Written Food Diary among Adolescents with Type 1 Diabetes. , 13(4) : 1319.
King N.,Horrocks C.,Brooks J. .2018 .Interviews in qualitative research: sage.. , : .
Labonté ,Kirkpatrick S. I.,Bell R. C.,Boucher B. A.,Csizmadi I.,Koushik A.,Lamarche B. .2016 .Dietary assessment is a critical element of health research - Perspective from the Partnership for Advancing Nutritional and Dietary Assessment in Canada. , 7 : .
Metabolism ,Hodson J. A.,Sharma L.,S. L.,Krebs S. A.,J. S. A. .2015 .. , 10(10) : 1096-1099.
Naska A.,Lagiou A.,Lagiou P. .2017 .Dietary assessment methods in epidemiological research: current state of the art and future prospects. F1000Research, : .
.2018 .Technology-based dietary assessment in youth with and without developmental disabilities. Nutrients, 10(10) : 1482.
.2019 .Feasibility and relative validity of a digital photo-based dietary assessment: results from the Nutris-Phone study. Public health nutrition, 22(7) : 1160-1167.
.2019 .Nutritional risk screening and assessment. Journal of clinical medicine, 8(7) : 1065.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

48

Views