No Detail Found!

Determination of Subclinical Mastitis Prevalence in Dairy Cows in Türkiye through Meta- Analysis and Production Loss Calculation

Author(s)
Mehmet Saltuk Arikan Department of Animal Health Economics and Management, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Fırat University,Elazıg,Turkiye
Burak Mat Department of Animal Health Economics and Management, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Selçuk University,Konya,Turkiye
Hasan Alkan Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Selcuk University,Konya,Turkiye
Mustafa Bahadır Çevrimli Department of Animal Health Economics and Management, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Selçuk University,Konya,Turkiye
Ahmet Cumhur Akin Department of Animal Health Economics and Management, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Mehmet Akif Ersoy University,Burdur,Turkiye
Ebru Kaya Başar Akdeniz University Statistics Consultancy Application and Research Center, Akdeniz University,Antalya,Turkiye
Mustafa Agah Tekindal Department of Biostatistics, Faculty of Medicine, İzmir Katip Çelebi University,İzmir,Turkiye
Abstract
In recent years, many studies have been conducted on mastitis, and preventive measures have been taken to curb it. However, mastitis continues to cause great economic losses in dairy farms and negatively affects high-yielding dairy cows. The current study aims to consolidate the prevalence of subclinical mastitis among dairy cows in Türkiye and to estimate economic losses due to mastitis. The random-effects model (Sidik-Jonkman Knapp and Hartung method) was used for the meta-analysis to determine between-study and within-study variances. Economic losses due to subclinical mastitis were calculated on the prevalence value calculated by meta-analysis. Analyses revealed a high heterogeneity between studies based on cows (Q = 1,590.86, df = 25, p < 0.01, I 2 = 98.21) and udder lobes (Q = 732,802, df = 21, p < 0.001, I2 = 97.83). The pooled estimate of subclinical mastitis prevalence in 10,334 cows from 26 studies was 44.13% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 36.00-52.50). A meta-analysis consisting of 21,745 udder lobes from 22 studies revealed the prevalence of udder lobe-based subclinical mastitis to be 31.44% (95% CI: 27.00-36.20). The meta-analysis yielded statistically high heterogeneity for prevalence estimates in published studies. The economic analysis revealed an economic loss of 1,095.88, 3,221.26, and 8,455.91 TL (equivalent to 233.17, 685.37, and 1,799.13 L of milk, 84.3, 247.8 and 650.5 USD$) per animal in mild, moderate, and severe cases, respectively. In this study, Meta-analysis in Türkiye reveals varying subclinical mastitis prevalence, addressing inconsistencies across studies. These economic loss calculations provide producers, policymakers, and other stakeholders in the industry with the scientific information necessary to develop effective strategies to combat subclinical mastitis.
Publication Details
Page(s) 391-399
Published Journal: Pakistan Veterinary Journal, Volume: 44, Issue: 2, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
prevalence, Meta-analysis, Subclinical, Mastitis Cost-analysis
References
Abay M and Bekyürek T .2006 .Laktasyondaki sütçü ineklerde staphylococcus aureus'un neden olduğu subklinik mastitislerin tedavisinde sefkuinom ve amoksisilin+ klavulanik asit'in etkinliklerinin karşılaştırılması. Sağ Bil Derg, 15(3) : 189-193.
Ayvazoğlu DP,Eşki F .2019 .Estimate by quantitative methods of the effect on some milk yield traits with cmt score of subclinic mastitis in cows: pilot study. Van Vet J, 30(3) : 177-182.
Bareille N,Beaudeau F,Billon S .2003 .Effects of health disorders on feed intake and milk production in dairy cows. Livest Prod Sci, 83(1) : 53-62.
Bangar YC,Singh B,Dohare AK .2015 .A systematic review and meta-analysis of prevalence of subclinical mastitis in dairy cows in India. Trop Anim Health Prod 47, (2) : 291-297.
Baştan A,Baskı A .2019 .İneklerde meme sağlığı ve sorunları. 3. , : .
Bennett R .2003 .The 'direct costs' of livestock disease: the development of a system of models for the analysis of 30 endemic livestock diseases in Great Britain. J Agric Econ, 54(1) : 55-71.
Birhanu M,Leta S,Mamo G .2017 .Prevalence of bovine subclinical mastitis and isolation of its major causes in Bishoftu Town, Ethiopia. BMC Res Notes, 10 : 767.
Borenstein M,Hedges LV,Higgins JP .2011 .Introduction to metaanalysis. , : .
CBAT ,Price Livestock .2021 .. , 17 : 11.
Cheng WN,Han SG .2020 .Bovine mastitis: risk factors, therapeutic strategies, and alternative treatments-A review. Asianaustralas J Anim Sci, 33(11) : 1699.
Cochran WG .1954 .The combination of estimates from different experiments. Biometrics, 10(1) : 101-129.
Cynthia MK .2005 .The Merck Veterinary Manual, Merck. , : .
Çelik Ö .2020 .Aydın İli söke ilçesinde siyah-alaca sütçü ineklerde subklinik mastitis prevalansının belirlenmesi. Adnan Menderes Üniversitesi, : .
Akçay Çelik E,A Çelik E .2024 .Meta-analysis and meta-regression of subclinical mastitis prevalences in dairy cattle in Türkiye. Ankara Univ Vet Fak Derg, 72(2) : .
Cobirka M,Tancin V,Slama P .2020 .Epidemiology and classification of mastitis. Animals, 10(12) : 2212.
Çokal Y,Konuş R .2012 .Subklinik mastitisli ineklerin sütlerinden aerobik bakterilerin izolasyonu. Balıkesir Sağ Bil Derg, 1(2) : 65-69.
Erer H,Ateş M,Kıran MM .1996 .İneklerde mastitislerin patolojik ve bakteriyolojik incelenmesi. Vet Bil Derg, 12 : 123-133.
Ergün Y,Aslantaş Ö,Doğruer G .2004 .Hatay ilindeki aile tipi süt sığırcılığı işletmelerinde subklinik mastitislerin epidemiyolojisi. Vet Bil Derg, 20(4) : 25-28.
Ergün Y,Köker A,Musal B,Fuerst-Waltl B,Fuerst C,Obritzhauser W .2016 .Sustainable breeding objectives and possible selection response: Finding the balance between economics and breeders' preferences. J Dairy Sci, 99(12) : 9796-9809.
Geary U,Lopez-Villalobos N,O'Brien B .2013 .Examining the impact of mastitis on the profitability of the Irish dairy industry. Irish J Agric Food Res 135-149., : .
Gezgen C .2015 .Sığır Mastitislerinden İzole Edilen Stafilokoklarda Metisilin Direnci ve Panton-Valentine Lökosidin Varlığının Araştırılması. , : .
Gonçalves JL,Kamphuis C,Martins CMMR .2018 .Bovine subclinical mastitis reduces milk yield and economic return. Lives Sci, 210 : 25-32.
Gülcü HB,Ertas HB .2004 .Elazığ yöresinde mezbahada kesilen ineklerde mastitisli meme loblarının bakteriyolojik inclenmesi. Turk J Vet Anim Sci, 28(1) : 91-94.
Halasa T,Huijps K,Østerås O .2007 .Economic effects of bovine mastitis and mastitis management: A review. Vet Q, 29(1) : 18-31.
Hiitiö H,Vakkamäki J,Simojoki H .2017 .Prevalence of subclinical mastitis in Finnish dairy cows: changes during recent decades and impact of cow and herd factors. Acta Vet Scand, 59(1) : 1-14.
Hogeveen H,Østerås O .2005 .Mastitis Management in an Economic Framework. Proceedings of 4th IDF International Dairy Conference: Mastitis in Dairy ProductionCurrent Knowledge and Future Solutions, : .
Hogeveen H,Huijps K,Lam TJGM .2011 .Economic aspects of mastitis: new developments. N Z Vet J, 59(1) : 16-23.
Hogeveen H,Steeneveld W,Wolf CA .2019 .Production diseases reduce the efficiency of dairy production: A review of the results, methods, and approaches regarding the economics of mastitis. Annu Rev Resour Econ, 11 : 289-312.
Seegers Hortet P,H Hortet P .1998 .Loss in milk yield and related composition changes resulting from clinical mastitis in dairy cows. Prev Vet Med, 37(1-4) : 1-20.
IntHout J,Ioannidis JP,Borm GF .2014 .The Hartung-Knapp-SidikJonkman method for random effects meta-analysis is straightforward and considerably outperforms the standard DerSimonian-Laird method. BMC Med Res Methodol, 14(1) : 1-12.
Joshi S and Gokhale S .2006 .Status of Mastitis as an Emerging Disease in Improved and Peri urban Dairy Farms in India. Annals of the New York Academy of Sci, 1081 : 74-83.
Kaya A,Uzmay C,Kaya I,İli Holstein Damızlık Süt Sığırı Yetiştirici Birliği İşletmelerinde Mastitisin Yaygınlık İzmir .2001 .Düzeyi ve Etkileyen Etmenler Üzerine Araştırmalar 1. Ege Üniv Zir Fak Derg, 38(1) : 63-70.
Çolak Kireçci E,A Kireçci E .2002 .Kuru dönem başlangıcında subklinik mastitisli ineklerden izole edilen stafilokok suşlarında metisilin direnci. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 8(2) : 98-100.
Hartung Knapp G,J Knapp G .2003 .Improved tests for a random effects meta-regression with a single covariate. Stat Med, 22(17) : 2693-2710.
Koçyiğit R,Mudurnu Bölgesinde Bulunan Süt İneklerinde Subklinik Mastitis İnsidansının Belirlenmesi. Afyon Kocatepe Bolu,Üniversitesi Bolu .2012 .. , : .
Koçyiğit R,Yılmaz O,Özenç E .2016 .Effect of some risk factors on subclinical mastitis in dairy cows. Kocatepe Vet J, 9(3) : 185-193.
Krishnamoorthy P,Goudar AL,Suresh KP .2021 .Global and countrywide prevalence of subclinical and clinical mastitis in dairy cattle and buffaloes by systematic review and meta-analysis. Res Vet Sci, 136 : 561-586.
Krupová Z,Krupa E,Michaličková M .2016 .Economic values for health and feed efficiency traits of dual-purpose cattle in marginal areas. J Dairy Sci, 99(1) : 644-656.
Krupová Z,Zavadilová L,Wolfová M .2019 .Udder and clawrelated health traits in selection of czech holstein cows. Ann Anim Sci, 19(3) : 647-661.
Kvapilík J,Hanuš O,Bartoň L .2015 .Mastitis of dairy cows and financial losses: an economic meta-analysis and model calculation. Bulgarian J Agri Sci, 21(5) : 1092-1105.
Macun HC,Yağcı İP,Ünal N .2011 .de belirlenen subklinik mastitisli ineklerde etken izolasyonu ve antibiyotik direnç durumu. Erciyes Üniv Vet Fak Derg, 8(2) : 91-95.
McInerney JP,Howe KS,Schepers JA .1992 .A framework for the economic analysis of disease in farm livestock. Prev Vet Med, 13(2) : 137-154.
Moher D,Liberati A,Tetzlaff J .2009 .Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med, 6(7) : 16-21.
Mpatswenumugabo JP,Bebora LC,Gitao GC .2017 .Prevalence of subclinical mastitis and distribution of pathogens in dairy farms of Rubavu and Nyabihu districts. Rwanda. J Vet Med, : .
Nielsen C .2009 .Economic impact of mastitis in dairy cows. ISBN: 978-91-86195-76-2, 29 : .
Nyaga VN,Arbyn M,Aerts M .2014 .Metaprop: a Stata command to perform meta-analysis of binomial data. Arch Pub Health, 72(1) : 1-10.
Özdemir FÖ .2018 .Subklinik mastitisli sığırlardan major patojenlerin izolasyonu ve antibiyotiklere duyarlılıklarının belirlenmesi. Adnan Menderes Üniversitesi, : .
Özenç E .2019 .Determination of risk factors associated with subclinical mastitis as detected by California Mastitis Test in smallholder dairy farms in Afyonkarahisar. Kocatepe Vet J, 12(3) : 277-283.
Patsopoulos NA,Evangelou E,Ioannidis JP .2008 .Sensitivity of between-study heterogeneity in meta-analysis: proposed metrics and empirical evaluation. Int J Epid, 37(5) : 1148-1157.
Ranasinghe RMSBK,Deshapriya RMC,Abeygunawardana DI .2021 .Subclinical mastitis in dairy cows in major milk-producing areas of Sri Lanka: Prevalence, associated risk factors and effects on reproduction. J Dairy Sci, 104(12) : 12900-12911.
Rişvanlı A,Türkiye Rollin E,Dhuyvetter KC,Overton MW .2015 .The cost of clinical mastitis in the first 30 days of lactation: An economic modeling tool. Prev Vet Med, 122(3) : 257-264.
Sağlam AG,Otlu S,Çoșkun MR .2018 .Prevalence of subclinical mastitis in cows, isolation of agents and determination of their antibiotic susceptibility. Eurasian J Vet Sci, 34(2) : 92-98.
Sarıözkan S .2019 .de süt sığırcılığı işletmelerinde mastitis nedeniyle oluşan finansal kayıpların tahmin edilmesi. Harran Üniv Vet Fak Derg, 8(2) : 147-151.
Saydan M .2017 .Malatya arguvan yöresinde süt ineklerinde subklinik mastitis prevalansı. Fırat Üniversitesi, : .
Seegers H,Fourichon C,Beaudeau F .2003 .Production effects related to mastitis and mastitis economics in dairy cattle herds. Vet Res, 34(5) : 475-491.
Sevinti DA,Şahin M .2009 .Sığır mastitislerinden izole edilen stafilokok suşlarının beta-laktamaz aktivitesi ve bazı antibiyotiklere karşı duyarlılıklarının saptanması. Eurasian J Vet Sci, 25(1-2) : 23-28.
Sharma N .2010 .Economically important production diseases of dairy animals. Farm Managament & Dıseases. SMVS' Dairy Year Book, 47 : .
Sidik K,Jonkman JN .2002 .A simple confidence interval for metaanalysis. Stat Med, 21(21) : 3153-3159.
Şahin M,Colak A,Otlu S .1997 .Studies on the prevalence of subclinic and clinic mastitis and antibiotic sensitivity in imported simmental cows in Kars district. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 3 : 49-55.
Tel OY,Keskin O,Zonturlu AK .2009 .Şanlıurfa yöresinde subklinik mastitislerin görülme oranı, aerobik bakteri izolasyonu ve duyarlı antibiyotiklerin belirlenmesi. FÜ Sağ Bil Vet Derg, 23(2) : 101-106.
TNDC ,Price Milk .2021 .. Accessed: 12.11, : .
Unal N and Yildirim M .2010 .Antibiotic resistance profiles of Staphylococci species isolated from milks, teat skins and noses mucous of cows. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 16(3) : 389-396.
Wilson DJ,Gonzalez RN,Das HH .1997 .Bovine mastitis pathogens in New York and Pennsylvania: prevalence and effects on somatic cell count and milk production. J Dairy Sci, 80(10) : 2592-2598.
Yalçın C,Sariozkan S,Yildiz AS .2006 .Financial losses from clinical mastitis in Turkish dairy herds. In Proceedings of the 57th Annual Meeting of the European Association for Animal Production, 20 : 261.
Yalçın C,Cevger Y,Türkyılmaz K .2000 .Süt ineklerinde subklinik mastitisten kaynaklanan süt verim kayıplarının tahmini. Turk J Vet Anim Sci, 24 : 599-604.
Yeşilmen S,Özyurtlu N,Bademkıran S .2012 .Diyarbakır yöresinde subklinik mastitisli ineklerde etken izolasyonu ve duyarlı antibiyotiklerin belirlenmesi. Dicle Üniv Vet F Derg, 1 : 24-29.
Yıldız AŞ,Yalçın C .2014 .Ankara ili süt sığırcılığı işletmelerinde klinik mastitis kaynaklı ekonomik kayıplar. Dicle Üniv Vet F Derg, 2(2) : 55-62.
Zavadilová L,Kašná E,Krupová Z .2021 .Health traits in current dairy cattle breeding: A review. Czech J Anim Sci, 66(7) : 235-250.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

109

Views