No Detail Found!

Assessing the quality and standards of operative notes in general surgery; A teaching institute's experience in Pakistan

Author(s)
Muhammad Danish Muneeb Baqai Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Mirza Agha Naushad Baig Baqai Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Muhammad Kamran Baqai Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Shafaatullah Qudratullah Baqai Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Muhammad Saddique Arain Baqai Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Abstract
Objective: To evaluate the quality and standard of hand-written operative notes in a teaching institute. Methods: This prospective study was carried out in the department of surgery, Fatima Hospital, Baqai Medical University, from January 2023 till May 2023. One hundred fifty operative notes from general surgery domain were considered. These notes were evaluated according to the guidelines of Royal College of Surgeons, with added-on a few variables by the author. Results: All 150 notes were handwritten. Resident surgeon wrote the operative notes under the supervision of primary surgeon. There was a deficiency in mentioning medical record number, procedure starting time and duration of surgery. An important statement about the hemostasis is that it is secured-per-operatively was not documented. The residents were reluctant to explain the surgical procedures diagrammatically. The operative room number was missing in all notes. Post operative instructions lacked the information for nothing per oral, blood pressure, temperature, pulse rate, and input and output charting. Conclusion: It is observed that the operative surgical notes were however explainable about the procedure, but quality and standard was not matchable with that of Royal College of Surgeons notes. Hence, a lack of formal training for the resident surgeons in operative notes writing was observed. This study is a thought provoker to the surgeons and a guide to resident trainees, and hospital management to provide a handful operative notes writing theme in the form of performa provided in the department.
Publication Details
Page(s) 1837-1840
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences, Volume: 40, Issue: 8, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Operative notes, General Surgery, Quality, postoperative care, Resident surgeon, Duration of Surgery
References
Hamza AA,Abdalrahim HM,Idris SA,Ahmed OM .2013 .Evaluating the operative notes of patients undergoing surgery at Omdurman teaching hospital. Sudan. Sch J App Med Sci, 1(6) : 668-672.
Audit S,Orthopaedics RC,Blackburn J .2016 .Assessing the quality of operation notes: a review of 1092 operation notes in 9 UK hospitals. Patient Saf Surg, 10 : .
Hossain T,Hossain N. .2015 .Guidance on writing general surgical operation notes: a review of the literature. Int Surg J, 10 : 2349-2902.
Coughlan F,Ellanti P,Fhoghlu CN,Moriarity A,Hogan N. Audit,Orthop Surg Documentation Surg Res Pract N. Audit .2015 .. , 10 : 9-12.
Jawaid M,Askari R,Qureshi MA .2008 .Quality of operative notes. J Postgrad Med Inst, 22 : 274-276.
Wauben LSGL,Goossens RH,Lange JF .2010 .. Evaluation of Operative Notes Concerning Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy: Are Standards Being Met? World J Surg, 10(5) : 903-909.
Mannan F,Gill RC,Sohail AA,Alvi R .2021 .Assessing the Adherence of Operative Notes for Laparoscopic Appendectomy with the Royal College of Surgeons Guidelines. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak, 02(2) : 202-205.
Surgical Good .2014 .Royal College of Surgeons (England) Available from. , : .
Lefter LP,Walker SR,Dewhurst F,Turner RW .2008 .An audit of operative notes: facts and ways to improve. ANZ J Surg, 04654(9) : 2197-802.
Younis MU .2021 .. Importance Of Efficient Operation Note Writing: Review of Guidance. J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad-Pakistan, 33(1) : 145-149.
Vijayakumar S,Divakaran S,Khan I .2022 .. Audit on the Quality of Operation Notes in Otolaryngology: Based on Electronic Template. Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 10(3) : 439-441.
Shah S,Dangol B,Kumari S,Guragain RP,Nepalese J ENT Head Neck Surg RP .2011 .An audit of operative notes at TUTH. , 10(2) : 6802-26.
Ma GW,Pooni A,Forbes SS,Eskicioglu C,Pearsall E,Brenneman FD .2013 .. Quality of Inguinal Hernia Operative Reports: Room for Improvement. Can J Surg, 10(6) : 393-397.
Parrish AB,Sanaiha Y,Petrie BA,Russell MM,Chen F .2016 .Examining the quality of rectal cancer operative reports in teaching institutions: is there an opportunity for resident education?. Am Surg, 82(10) : 1023-1027.
Ebbers T,Kool RB,Smeele LE,Dirven R,Karssemakers Luc HE .2022 .The impact of structured and standardized documentation on documentation quality; a multicenter, retrospective study. J Med Syst, 10 : 46.
Ghosh AK .2010 .An audit of orthopedic operation notes: what are we missing?. Clin Audit, 10 : 37-40.
Kawu AA,Sha DG,Salami OOA,Olawepo A,Kuranga SA,Jeje EA .2011 .Operative notes in orthopaedic surgical care in Nigeria. Int J Biol Med Res, 2(3) : 668-670.
Mannan F,Gill RC,Sohail AA,Alvi AR .2021 .Assessing the adherence of operative notes for laparoscopic appendectomy with the royal college of surgeons guidelines. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak, 02(2) : 202.
Williams H,Lees C,Boyd M. The General Medical Council C .2023 .. , 22 : .
Chan BKY,Exarchou K,Corbett HJ,Turnock RR .2015 .The Impact of an Operative Note Proforma at a Paediatric Surgical Centre. J Ev in Clin Prac, 10 : 74-78.
Shayah A,Agada FO,Gunasekaran S,Jassar P,England RJ .2007 .The quality of operative note taking: an audit using the Royal College of Surgeons Guidelines as the gold standard. Int J Clin Pract, 01292(4) : 1241-679.
Gul F,Nazir M,Abbas K,Khan AA,Malick DS,Khan H .2022 .Surgical safety checklist compliance: The clinical audit. Ann Med Surg (Lond), 104397 : 104397.
Ghani Y,Thakrar R,Kosuge D,Bates P. .2013 .Smart' electronic operation notes in surgery: an innovative way to improve patient care. Int J Surg, 10(5) : 30-32.
Theivendran K,Hassan S,I Clark D S .2016 .Improving the quality of operative notes by implementing a new electronic template for upper limb surgery at the Royal Derby Hospital. BMJ Qual Improv Rep, 10(1) : u208727.
Payne K,Jones K,Dickenson A .2011 .Improving the standard of operative notes within an oral and maxillofacial surgery department, using an operative note proforma. J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 10(3) : 203-208.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

118

Views