The present study investigated the effects of crossed category membership on inter-group evaluations for the in-groups and out-groups. The participants of the study were 400 Pakistani Muslims and Christians. Four hypotheses, derived from models of cross categorization and Social Identity Theory (SIT), were investigated. Our strategy involved requesting the respondents to conceive of both their religious and social class identity and then rate either their in-groups or out-groups on positive and negative traits. Median test was used to analyze the ratings on each trait. The findings revealed more evidence for category conjunction model predicting bias for intermediate categories as comparable to that for double in-groups and out-groups. Secondly, inter-group prejudice does not seem to operate on an all or none basis. Target groups favored on positive traits were also perceived as possessing negative traits at the same time and this holds for in-groups as well. Thirdly, socio-economic class seems to be an important factor in shaping patterns of inter-group bias so that respondents from relatively upper class showed more out-group derogation than those from lower socioeconomic status. Implications for social identity are discussed in light of SIT.