Soil mechanical impedance (MI) and matric potential can both cause reduction in the root growth rate, modify rooting pattern and root diameter. Cotton seedlings are sensitive to the soil physical environment, particularly during early stages of growth. Soil matric potential and MI effect on root biomass, axial root length and diameter, and the number and length of lateral roots in soil packed to penetration resistances (PR) of 0.1, 1.0, 1.1 and 1.2 MPa (megaPascal = 106 Pascal), each at three matric potentials of −10, −100 and −500 kPa (kiloPascal = 103 Pascal), were determined. Total root lengths were reduced by 29, 50 and 53% at impedance of 1.0, 1.1 and 1.2 MPa, respectively, as compared to the control, whereas MI of 1.2 MPa resulted in 60% reduction in axial root length. A similar increase in diameter was caused by increasing mechanical impedance, while decreasing matric potential had little effect. Roots that were water stressed did not change their diameter but had a shorter axis and longer lateral length. In contrast, the impeded roots (PR = 1.0, 1.1 and 1.2 MPa) had both a shorter axis and a smaller total length, but had increased diameter. These results not only illustrate the plasticity of root response to stress but also demonstrate how the response differs between different types of stresses.