The current study was aimed at a comparative analysis of heavy metals (lead, cadmium, and chromium) concentrations in the gills, kidneys, and liver of two fish species (Catla catla and Labeo rohita from Head Balloki, Pattoki, Punjab, Pakistan). The atomically coupled plasma optical emission spectrometer was used to assess heavy metal concentrations in selected tissues. Three major heavy metals-chromium, cadmium, and lead were examined in tissues. Heavy metal concentrations varied significantly depending on the type of fish tissue. Lead exhibits higher concentrations than chromium and cadmium in the kidney, liver, and gills. In case of liver the concentration of lead in L. rohita was 0.033±0.002 ppm (mg/kg) and in C. catla was 0.044±0.002 ppm (mg/kg), in case of gills the concentration of lead in L. rohita was 0.011±0.002 ppm (mg/kg) and in C. catla was 0.025±0.002 ppm (mg/kg) while in case of kidney the concentration of lead in L. rohita was 0.16±0.002 ppm (mg/kg) and in C. catla was 0.214±0.002 ppm (mg/kg). The order of concentration of lead in the tissues of both fish was kidney>liver>gills. Elevated levels of lead found in the organs of fish suggest that the fish may be at risk of harm. Among the studied metals, the order of concentration of heavy metals was lead >chromium>cadmium. The order of concentration of cadmium, chromium, and lead in L. rohita and C. catla tissue was kidney>gills>liver. Also, L. rohita was found to have a higher heavy metal accumulation than C. catla. There is concern that people may be exposed to harmful levels of heavy metals from eating these fish over the long term. We need more detailed investigations to fully understand this critical problem.