Organic and mineral nitrogen (N) fertilizers are important measures to increase wheat yield and sustain fertility and productivity of soil. Field experiments were therefore carried out to study the effect of different organic (composted and non-composted) and inorganic N fertilizer on wheat productivity, quality and soil fertility at Agronomy Research Farm, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar in winter 2017-2018 and 2018-2019. The experiments were laid out in randomized complete block design with 3 replications. Plot size of 3m x 4m having 10 rows with row to row distance of 30 cm was maintained. Wheat variety Pirsabak-2015 was sown at the seed rate of 120 kg ha-1. Organic sources of nitrogen (rice residue, mungbean residue and cattle manure) in two forms (compost and non-compost) with different N ratios (100% organic: 0% inorganic, 75% organic: 25% inorganic, 50% organic: 50% inorganic, 25% organic: 75% inorganic, 0% organic: 100% inorganic) were tested in the experiments. Urea was used as inorganic fertilizer source. A total of 120 kg N ha-1 was maintained from different nitrogen sources. The results of the experiments revealed significant effect of different sources, forms and ratios of nitrogen on wheat yield, quality and soil parameters. Among different organic sources of nitrogen, application of cattle manure enhanced grains spike-1 (52 grains), thousand grains weight (43.8 g), grain yield (3546 kg ha-1), harvest index (41.5%), grain crude protein content (14.1%), grain gluten content (21.4%), grain nitrogen content (2.26%), soil organic carbon (0.77%) and soil total nitrogen (0.094%). Use of organic nitrogen sources in compost form improved the grain yield, grain quality, soil total N and organic carbon content as compared with organic sources incorporated in non-compost form. Regarding organicinorganic N ratios, 50% organic and 50% inorganic nitrogen application produced higher grains spike-1 (52), thousand grains weight (43.8 g), grain yield (3762 kg ha-1), harvest index (43.5%), grain wet gluten content (21.3%) and nitrogen content (2.28%). Plots that received sole organic nitrogen retained higher soil organic carbon (1.0%) and soil total nitrogen (0.092%). It is concluded that wheat crop performed better in soil applied with cattle manure as organic nitrogen source in compost form coupled with inorganic nitrogen in 50:50 ratios and hence recommended for further studies to authenticate higher wheat yield and soil fertility in the agro climatic conditions of Peshawar-Pakistan.