The content of secondary metabolites varies among different cultivars or varieties of Olea europaea. There is ever high increase of olive cultivation and utilization of its oil, fruit, and even leaves in various products for human consumption. There is an increase concern about characterization of different varietie and traceability of various parts of olive, as being used in food processing. The objective of this study was to assess the metabolomic profiling and antioxidant activity of drupes in five varieties of Olea europaea (Napali, K18, improved Napali, Galat and Kalamata) growing under the same environmental conditions in Aljouf region of Saudi Arabia. Spectrophotometer and HPLC combined with multivariate data as analytical and data processing strategy for this study, where four distinct groups were observed in principal component analysis based on metabolic discrimination among various varieties. Galat was clearly discriminated from others due to higher contents of total secondary metabolites (phenols, flavonoids, flavonols, tannins, and anthocyanins), high total antioxidant capacity (TAC), and high amounts of individual polyphenols, such as 2-hydroxybenzoic acid and ferulic acid. Further, K18 was separated into another group, by having least contents of all total metabolites, quercetin, and 2-hydroxybenzoic acid, but with higher contents of luteolin, luteolin-7-glucoside, syringic acid, and oleuropein. Napali and Kalamata were separated together into a third group, characterized by moderate contents of the total and individual secondary metabolites, as well as moderate TAC, but with a higher content of quercetin. The fourth group included the Improved Napali variety, with moderate contents of all metabolites and a higher content of caffeic acid. The antioxidant activity is discussed based on the polyphenol contents of each variety. The present study provides new insights into the factors controlling the selection of five olive varieties for either oil production or the pickling industry based on polyphenol distribution and total antioxidant activity.