Aim: To compare the effectiveness and safety among topical, sub-tenon and retro-bulbar anesthesia in 23-gauge pars plana vitrectomy (PPV). Study design: Randomized Control Trail. Place and duration of study: Vitreo-Retinal Unit, Ophthalmology Department, Al-Ehsan Welfare Eye Hospital, Lahore, from July 2019 to December 2019. Methods: 45 patients requiring pars plana vitrectomy (PPV) were randomized into Group A (topical anesthesia), Group B (sub-tenon anesthesia) and Group C (retro-bulbar anesthesia), and underwent 23-gauge PPV. A pain scale (VAPS) was used to assess patients' pain experience during administration of anesthesia, pain during surgery, and postoperative pain. Results:The results showed that there is statistically significant difference in the pain score between the different anesthetic routes of administration. The least painful route of administration was topical with a mean pain score of 8.00 while a score of 31.00 for retro bulbar anesthesia. However with per-operative mean pain score of 10.87 and 13.73 post operatively, retro bulbar anesthesia was the most comfortable. Conclusion: The study suggested that topical anesthesia is a safe and effective anesthetic approach for patients undergoing 23G PPV along with other methods sub-tenon and retro bulbar anesthesia. It helps with the conduct of high volume surgeries by reducing requirements and burden on the healthcare team however retro bulbar and sub tenon anesthesia are the most potent in reducing per-operative and post-operative pain during surgery.