Field studies were conducted on two promising sugarcane varieties CPF-237 and HSF-240 to evaluate the comparative effects of stale and fresh seed on agronomic and qualitative characteristics. Both varieties responded analogous decreasing trend for germination, tillering, cane yield and sugar yield when sown stale seed of 72, 144, 216 and 288 hours after harvesting over fresh cane. Stale seed on an average basis decreased germination 13.95, 21.72, 33.13 and 42.56%, tillering 3.77, 6.60, 10.38 and 13.20% and cane yield 9.75, 19.23, 34.75 and 44.55% respectively as compared with fresh seed setts sowing. However, commercial cane sugar showed an erratic trend. The study concluded that sowing of fresh setts was utmost important for prompt germination, profused tillering and bumper yield.