Rapid development of information technology and communication (ICT) has increased the use of information systems in companies. At the same time, many organizations are still using old systems to support their business (legacy systems). Even though these systems cause technical problems, but they are still used to support service delivery to the customer. These systems are also essential to organizations as they have been operated for many years and possess high business value Legacy system modernization (LSM) decision is very challenging and problematic issues in many organisations. In this Systematic Literature Review (SLR) paper, we describe the problem from a theoretical perspective, followed by models and approaches for its effectiveness. We present trends in decision-models and approaches and the resulting implications on practicality strategies. We then review the multicriteria decision-making (MCDM) application in LSM. Additionally, we present all relevant works classified by the year of publication, MCDM techniques, journals, and conferences in which they appeared. We discuss significant criteria identified to support researchers and industry practitioners by adopting the MCDM techniques to their LSM and providing insights into the state-of-the-art approaches or models, respectively. The study successfully managed to answer the three presented research questions.