The stream in which every bit of information shared and viewed has been rapidly increasing at the current era, with speed like never unlike in previous generations. Because of that, there is dire need to effectively secure this information stream in order to prevent compromise from any risk and threats. This is particularly true for government sector that holds highly classified information crucial for the country operations. Indonesia government strive to protect and to better maintain information through an adoption of a robust security implementation within the many bodies of government throughout the country, however for an implementation to be robust the first time is near impossible. Robustness is achieved through rigor evaluation that actively assess the performance and effectiveness of that implementation to know its resiliency in withstanding attacks and efficient in its application. For this reason, KAMI Index is developed in order to evaluate and assess the maturity and the readiness of information security in each government agency, but does it reliable and accurate? To answer, this research will make a comparison to an existing evaluation frameworks or models proposed by other researchers that study the topic of information security with regards to different aspects that exists within it. By making a comparison, an analysis for an existing model what aspects that they do better or best compared to KAMI Index can be perform so that a suitable recommendation and suggestion can be made. This research will be conducted through Systematic Literature Review (SLR) methodology, this paper will also provide an explanation of alternatives information security evaluation models or frameworks, and the reason why these models can be used to improve or even replace the KAMI Index model. Results from this research includes an alternatives models to KAMI Index and identified IS aspects crucial for evaluation.