This study evaluated the level of self-efficacy and level of preparedness of the Pre-service Teachers in Caraga State University Cabadbaran City (CSUCC), Philippines, with regards to professional and personal attributes. The results of this study would be the basis for enhancement on policy guidelines, evaluation instruments, and further training. There was 133 population of Pre-service Teachers from S.Y. 2017 - 2020 for this study. This study utilized a mixed-method design that combined quantitative and qualitative research methods. The study employed quantitative research assessing the frequency and meaning of the data. The study also made use of the qualitative research method through the use of Thematic Analysis. The results showed that Professional Attribute has an overall mean of 3.88 (SD = 0.56) while the Personal Attribute has a mean of 3.72 (SD=0.49), with both attributes, having a verbal interpretation of Fully Practiced. When it comes to Self-efficacy even amidst the pandemic, Pre-service Teachers got an overall mean of 4.16 (SD=0.95) and a verbal interpretation of High Efficacy. This means that the Pre-service teachers had confidence in themselves when it comes to teaching. However, this may also indicate that there were areas that need improvement to attain the Highest Level of Self-Efficacy of the Pre-service Teachers. Furthermore, there were two major themes for Suggestions and Comments: areas needed for improvement and areas that were performed well. Under the first theme, there was a need to improve for the following: Classroom Management and Boundaries, Communication Skills and Voice Modulation, and Self-confidence. Under the second theme, the following areas are good practices: Good Attitude, Teaching Techniques and Skills, and Creative Materials.