This study investigates the expanse to which a set of criteria in oral proficiency skills was tested among the Senior High School (SHS) students in this time of the pandemic. The organization, topic knowledge, language use, and delivery are the main criteria in assessing the SHS students' oral proficiency skills. Data were collected from 60 non-native senior high school students who are enrolled in Oral Communication subject. Speaking tests were conducted to determine their oral proficiency skills. Based on the data gathered, the study found out that SHS students lacked transitional words to connect their ideas and also coherence seemed to be another concern for the Organization criteria while for Topic knowledge and Language use, students are having problems in elaborating their ideas for they cannot directly supply apt words and thoughts; And for their Delivery, minimal eye-to-eye contact with the audience was observed, low tones, pronunciation, and articulation of words are not that good. The study recommends that teachers and school administrators may develop a suitable compendium of activities in order for these students to practice better in harnessing their oral skills. Moreover, teachers can give them drills and exercises geared toward mastering these skills for them not just to be equipped but to be able to communicate effectively and attain academic success.