To compare the frequency of various postoperative complications in open versus closed reduction and intramedullary nailing in cases of closed tibial shaft fractures. Settings: This Comparative prospective study was conducted at Orthopedic Surgery Department, Khairpur Materials and Methods: Hundred and seventy patients selected for this study were divided into Group C (Closed percutaneous) and group O (Open). A closed percutaneous procedure was performed through a small stab incision. Reduction and stabilization of fracture were accomplished with large forceps and manual traction. Open reduction was achieved through an adequate incision for exposure and then directly reducing the fracture. The reduction was maintained with the help of clamps. Results: Surgical site infection was seen in 5 (5.88%) patients in group C and 9 (10.58%) in group O (pvalue=0.404). Deep infection was seen in 3 (3.53%) patients in group C and 7 (8.34%) in group O (p-value=0.329). Mal-union was seen in 4 (4.71%) and 2 (2.35%) patients in group C and O respectively (p-value=0.682). Delayed union was seen in 4 (4.71%) and 3 (3.53%) patients in group C and O respectively (p-value=1.0). Non-union was seen in 2 (2.35%) and 1 (1.18%) patients in group C and O respectively (p-value=1.0). Conclusion: It is concluded in our study that there is no significant difference in the rate of postoperative complications in open versus closed reduction and intramedullary nailing in cases of closed tibial shaft fractures.