Objective: To find the better supraglottic airway device in terms of advantages, and complications, in short surgeries following anesthesia and paralysis. Study Design: Quasi-experimental study Place and Duration of Study: Combined Military Hospital Okara and Armed Forces Institute of Urology, Rawalpindi Pakistan, from July 2018 to July 2020. Methodology: Prospectively, 130 American Society of Anesthesiologist (ASA) 1, 2, and 3 patients, aged 15-60 years, scheduled for short urology or gynecological procedure were randomly divided into Group LMA (Group L, n=65) or i-gel group (Group G, n=65). Laryngeal mask airway and i-gel were inserted in respective groups after anesthesia induction and muscle paralysis. The parameters compared were: simplicity of insertion, time taken for insertion, insertion attempts, device exchanged, and complications rate of each device. The data thus obtained was analyzed with SPSS-16. Results: LMA group was similar to i-gel group for gender distribution 68 (52%) vs. 62(47%) and surgery type 60 (urology 46.2%) vs. gynecology 70 (53.8%). The successful insertion rate at first attempt (38.4% vs. 40.7%) was similar in both devices. The device was changed in 3.07% of i-gel patient's vs. 6.92% LMA group patients, and complication rate was not substantially different in either group (i-gel 5.3% vs. LMA 6%). The insertion time was less in i-gel group (17.62 sec ± 6.41 vs.22.06 sec ±7.92) which was statistically significant p=0.05. Conclusion: LMA and i-gel are the two supraglottic devices for maintaining airways with different indications from emergency lifesaving to routine surgical procedures but their use in situations like difficult intubation is well known. Both devices have their pros and cons but well-fitted i-gel has edge over LMA because of fewer complications and ease of insertion.