Objective: To compare the surface defects created on the ProTaper Next fi les versus HyFlex Electrical Discharge Machining if les after single clinical use in molars. Methods: The cross-sectional study was conducted in the dental department of the Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, from December 2018 to June 2019, and comprised Nickel-Titanium fi les belonging to HyFlex Electrical Discharge Machining and ProTaper Next to perform complete root canal treatment of molar teeth. The fi les were fi rst visually examined and then analysed under 25.6x magnifi cation using a stereomicroscope for the evaluation of surface defects. A photographic record was maintained and studied. Data was analysed using SPSS 23.0. Results: Of the 114 fi les, 38(33.3%) each were ProTaper Next X1, ProTaper Next X2 and HyFlex Electrical Discharge Machining. The number of fi les showing defects under microscopic evaluation were 17(14.9%). Deformation of the cutting edge was the most frequently seen defect type, found in 9(7.9%) fi les. The frequency of fractured fi les was 4(3.5%). The odds of microscopic defects in HyFlex Electrical Discharge Machining fi les was 2.64 times that of ProTaper Next fi les. Conclusion: Even after single clinical use, HyFlex Electrical Discharge Machining fi les were more likely to get microscopic defects on their surface compared to ProTaper files.