Peeragogy is a collection of the best practices of effective peer-learning and teaching utilizing technology. This pilot study examined the mathematics performance and engagement of students via Peeragogy at Central Mindanao University Senior High School. It aimed to: (a) find out the level of students' academic performance when exposed to Peeragogy and those exposed to non-Peeragogy in terms of pretest, posttest, and retention test; (b) determine the level of students' engagement in Mathematics when exposed to different pedagogy in terms of, pre-test scores, and posttest scores; (c) compare the academic performance of students in these two groups in terms of their posttest scores and retention test scores; (d) differentiate the level of students' engagement in mathematics when exposed to different interventions. The study made use of the quasi-experimental research design. It was conducted at Central Mindanao University Senior High School with the Grade 11 students as participants. The students' academic performance and engagement in Mathematics were gathered using validated instruments to answer the research problems. Results showed that students have performance ranging from very low performance in the pretest to low or moderate performance in the posttest and retention test. Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA) revealed that a significant difference existed in students' performance in terms of posttest as well as retention test while no significant difference was found in their engagement in Mathematics. Students in the Peeragogy group performed better in the posttest and retention test, however, both groups were comparably engaged in learning Mathematics.