The area contiguous with rural-urban fringe having low density scattered development is gaining importance due to its rich agricultural landscape, economic worth and potential to become urban in near future. In 2009, the Government of Punjab promulgated Land Use Rules introducing the concept of Peri-Urban Structure Plan (PUSP) for the first time in Pakistan. This study assesses practicality of the approach by establishing whether it will lead to urban sprawl or act as a containment strategy to ensure orderly and efficient pattern of peri-urban development. For this purpose, a set of criteria were derived from said rules and applied to assess the compliance of two case studies taken from amongst plans prepared so far in Punjab. The proposals were critically examined in the light of local development trends and international practices of planning. Ironically, these plans neither followed any growth model nor appear to be based on internationally tested and suggested approaches to deal with peri-urban areas. The implementation of such plans would inevitably lead to further urban sprawl. Thus, it is expedient that preparation of a PUSP only be allowed as part of the master plan of a city which should identify zones for infill/high density development to accommodate future population within existing urban area. In case of big cities, putting an urban growth boundary whilst planning residential and industrial suburbs, as part of regional plan, would be a more promising strategy.