No Detail Found!

Comparative Study of Propofol Vs Etomidate as An Induction Agent to Evaluate Hemodynamic Changes during Induction of Anesthesia in Controlled Hypertensive Patients.

Author(s)
Jigna Shah Dept. of Anesthesiology, GMERS Medical College & Civil Hospital, SG Highway, Near Gujarat High Court, Sola, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India
Ila Patel Dept. of Anesthesiology, GMERS Medical College & Civil Hospital, SG Highway, Near Gujarat High Court, Sola, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India
Amrita Guha Dept. of Anesthesiology, GMERS Medical College & Civil Hospital, SG Highway, Near Gujarat High Court, Sola, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India
Abstract
Background and Aim: An ideal inducing agent for general anesthesia should have hemodynamic stability, minimal respiratory side effects and rapid clearance. Presently there are a number of induction agents available. Present study was done with an aim to compare propofol with etomidate as an induction agent to evaluate hemodynamic changes during induction of anesthesia in controlled hypertensive patients.Methodology: A prospective randomized double blind study was conducted at our hospital. Sixty patients undergoing surgery under general anesthesia during April 2015 to April 2016 were randomly divided into two equal groups. Patients of Group-P were given inj fentanyl 2 µg/kg, followed by inj propofol 1-2 mg/kg; and patients of Group-E were given inj fentanyl 2 µg/kg, followed by inj etomidate 0.2- 0.4 mg/kg. Patients’ hemodynamic parameters like systolic blood pressure (SBP), diastolic blood pressure (DBP), mean arterial pressure and heart rate (HR) were recorded at regular intervals. Any adverse event like pain during injection, myoclonus etc. were noted.Results: Post-induction, heart rate did not change significantly in etomidate group, but in propofol group it decreased significantly compared to the pre-induction value (3.8% vs. 6.5%). The mean fall in SBP at T2 (3 min post induction) in Group-E was 4.7% which was less than that seen in Group-P (7.6%). Three min after induction the fall in DBP was observed to be 16.24% vs. 4.8% in Group-P vs. Group-E respectively. In etomidate group, post-induction SBP did not change significantly as compared to pre-induction. But in propofol group, SBP decreased significantly in post-induction. Post-induction, DBP did not change significantly in etomidate group, but the fall was significant in propofol group.Conclusion: Etomidate is better in maintaining the heart rate and blood pressure and hence preferable to propofol in controlled hypertensive patients during induction of general anesthesia.
Publication Details
Page(s) 361-367
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Anaesthesia, Pain and Intensive Care, Volume: 22, Issue: 3, Year: 2018

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Hypertension, Propofol, Etomidate, Systolic blood pressure, Hemodynamic changes
References
MccollumJ,DundeeJ, 2007.Comparison of induction characteristics of four intravenous agents,Anaesthesia 41 995 -1000
MollerPetrun,A , Kamenik,M., 2012.Bispectral index-guided induction of general anaesthesia in patients undergoing major abdominal surgery using propofol or etomidate: a double-blind, randomized, clinical trial,Br J Anaesth 110 388 -396
SaricaogluF,UzunS,ArunO,ArunF,AyparU., 2011.A clinical comparison of etomidate-lipuro, propofol and admixture at induction,Saudi J Anaesth 5 76509 -354X
LarsenJ,TorpP,NorrildK,SlothE., 2007.Propofol reduces tissue-Doppler markers of left ventricle function: a transthoracic echocardiographic study,DOI: 10 98 183 -188
2006.Propofol causes hypotension,Clinical Anesthesia 5th ed Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins 1246 -61
StoweD,BosnjakZ,KampineJ, 1992.,Thiopental on Function and Metabolism of Isolated Hearts. Anesth Analg 74 547 -558
SchmidtC,RoosensC,StruysM,DeryckY,Van NootenG,ColardynF, .Contractility in Humans after Coronary Artery Surgery, 91 58 -70
GaussA,HeinrichH,Wilder-Smith O, 1991.Echocardiographic assessment of the haemodynamic effects of propofol: a comparison with etomidate and thiopentone,Anaesthesia 46 99 -105
1992.Propofol versus etomidate in shorttime urologic surgery,Ann Fr Anesth Reanim 11 12 -16
1991.Etomidate vs. propofol to carry out suspension laryngoscopies,Eur J Anaesthesiol 8 141 -4
HarrisC,MurrayA,AndersonJ,GroundsR,MorganM., 1988.Effects of thiopentone, etomidate and propofol on the haemodynamic response to tracheal intubation,Anaesthesia 43 32 -36
ShahS,ChowdhuryI,BhargavaA,SabbharwalB, 2015.Comparison of hemodynamic effects of intravenous etomidate versus propofol during induction and intubation using entropy guided hypnosis levels,DOI: 10 31 155145 -9185
DasM,PradhanBK,SamantrayRC, iss4.Comparative Study On Haemodynamic Responses During Intubation Using Etomidate, Propofol And Thiopentone In Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy Surgeries,Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 80 150 -158
YağanÖ,TaşN,KüçükA,HancıV,YurtluB, 2015.Haemodynamic Responses to Tracheal Intubation Using Propofol, Etomidate and Etomidate-Propofol Combination in Anaesthesia Induction,DOI: 10 7 134 -140
KarkiG,SinghV,BarnwalA,Singh L, 2014.A Comparative Evaluation of Hemodynamic Characteristics Of The Three Induction Agents - Etomidate, Thiopentone And Propofol,DOI: 10 3 9133 -9141
PandeyA,MakhijaN,ChauhanS,DasS,KiranU,BisoiA, 2012.Effects of Etomidate and Propofol Induction on Hemodynamic and Endocrine Response in Patients Undergoing Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery on Cardiopulmonary Bypass,DOI: 10 02 48 -52
MorelJ,SalardM,CastelainC,BayonM,LambertP,VolaM, 2011.Haemodynamic consequences of etomidate administration in elective cardiac surgery: a randomized double-blinded study,DOI: 10 107 503 -509
SarkarM,LaussenP,ZurakowskiD,ShuklaA,KussmanB,OdegardKC, 2005.Hemodynamic Responses to Etomidate on Induction of Anesthesia in Pediatric Patients,Anesth Analg 0000166764 645 -650
HugCC,McLeskeyCH,NahrwoldML,RoizenMF,StanleyTH, 1993.Hemodynamic effects of propofol: Data from over 25,000 patients,Anesth Analg 77 S21 -9
MorganM,LumleyJ,WhitwamJG,Etomidate , A New,Water-Soluble Non-Barbiturate Intravenous Induction Agent. Lancet, 1975., 6736 92011 -5
GoodingJM,WengJT,SmithRA,BerningerGT,KirbyRR, 1979.Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Responses following Etomidate Induction of Anesthesia in Patients with Demonstrated Cardiac Disease,Anesth Analg 58 40 -41
EamesWO,RookeGA,WuRS,Bishop MJ, 1996.Comparison of the Effects of Etomidate, Propofol, and Thiopental on Respiratory Resistance after Tracheal Intubation, 84 1307 -1311
FruergaardK,JenstrupM,SchierbeckJ,Wiberg-Jørgensen F, 1991.Total intravenous anaesthesia with propofol or etomidate,Eur J Anaesthesiol 8 385 -391
LowsonS,GentJP,GoodchildCS, 1991.Convulsive thresholds in mice during the recovery phase from anaesthesia induced by propofol, thiopentone, methohexitone and etomidate,Br J Pharmacol 102 879 -882
BerensR,EbertT,KampineJ, 1990.A343 Inhibition Of Sympathetic Neural Outflow Contributes To The Hypotension During Propofol Induction In Humans, 73 -
EbertTJ,MuziM,BerensR,GoffD,KampineJP, 1992.Sympathetic Responses to Induction of Anesthesia in Humans with Propofol or Etomidate,Anesthesiology 76 725 -733
WagnerC,BickJ,JohnsonD,AhmadR,HanX,EhrenfeldJ, 2014.Etomidate Use and Postoperative Outcomes among Cardiac Surgery Patients, 120 579 -589
BuddeA,MetsB.,Pro, 2012.Etomidate is the ideal induction agent for a cardiac anesthetic,J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 08 180 -183
DhawanN,ChauhanS,KothariS,KiranU,DasS,MakhijaN., 2010.Hemodynamic Responses to Etomidate in Pediatric Patients with Congenital Cardiac Shunt Lesions,J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 02 802 -807
BoerF,BovillJ,RosP,OmmenH, 1991.Effect of thiopentone, etomidate and propofol on systemic vascular resistance during cardio- pulmonary bypass,Br J Anaesth 67 69 -72
EbertT,KanitzD,BerensR,KampineJ. A342, 1990.Etomidate induction maintains sympathetic outflow in humans,Anesthesiology 73 -
DiagoMC,AmadoJ,OteroM, 1988.Anti-adrenal action of a subanaesthetic dose of etomidate,Anaesthesia 43 2044 -645
CriadoA,MasedaJ,NavarroE,EscarpaA,AvelloF, 1980.Induction of anaesthesia with etomidate: haemodynamic study of 36 patients,Br J Anaesth 52 803 -806
GoodingJ,CorssenG, 1977.Effect of Etomidate on the Cardiovascular System,Anesth Analg 56 717 -719
LeesN,HendryJ, 1977.Etomidate in urological outpatient anaesthesia,Anaesthesia 32 2044 -597
BairdCR,HayAW,McKeownDW,RayDC, 2009.Rapid sequence induction in the emergency department: induction drug and outcome of patients admitted to the intensive care unit,Emerg Med 26 576 -579
ZedPJ,Abu-LabanRB,HarrisonDW, 2006.Intubating Conditions and Hemodynamic Effects of etomidate for rapid sequence intubation in the emergency department: an observational cohort study,Acad Emerg Med 13 378 -383
VinsonDR,BradburyDR, 2002.Etomidate for procedural sedation in emergency medicine,Annf Emerg Med 39 592 -598
KaushalRP,VatalA,PathakR, 2015.Effect of etomidate and propofol induction on hemodynamic and endocrine response in patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting/mitral valve and aortic valve replacement surgery on cardiopulmonary bypass,DOI: 10 18 154470 -9784
Batra R.K, 1984.Comparative evaluation of etomidate, propofol and thiopentone in short surgical procedures,Ind J Anesth 108 -
De JongF,MalliosC,JansenC,ScheckP,LambertsS.,Etomidate Suppresses, 1984.Adrenocortical Function by Inhibition of 1 lβ-Hydroxylation,DOI: 10.1210/jcem-59-6-1143 59 1143 -1147
FragenR,ShanksC,MolteniA,AvramM., 1984.Effects of Etomidate on Hormonal Responses to Surgical Stress, 61 652 -656
MullinsM,TheodoroDL, 2008.Lack of Evidence for Adrenal Insufficiency After Single-Dose Etomidate,Arch Surg 143 808 -
McPheeL,BadawiO,FraserG,LerwickP,RikerR,ZuckermanIH, 2013.Single-Dose Etomidate Is Not Associated With Increased Mortality in ICU Patients With Sepsis,Crit Care Med 41 774 -783
Nyman Y. Etomidate-(R)Lipuro, 2006.is associated with considerably less injection pain in children compared with propofol with added lidocaine,DOI: 10 97 536 -539
St PierreM,DunkelM,RutherfordA,HeringW., 2000.Does etomidate increase postoperative nausea? A double-blind controlled comparison of etomidate in lipid emulsion with propofol for balanced anaesthesia,Eur J Anaesthesiol 17 634 -641
MayerM,DoenickeA,NebauerA,HeptingL, 1996.Induction of anaesthesia with etomidate in lipid emulsion and propofol: haemodynamics and patient comfort,Anaesthesist 45 1082 -1084
KosarekL,HartSR,SchultzL,DiGiovanniN., 2011.Increase in Venous Complications Associated With Etomidate Use During a Propofol Shortage: An Example of Clinically Important Adverse Effects Related to Drug Substitution,Ochsner J 11 143 -146
IsitemizI,UzmanS,ToptaşM,VahapogluA,GülYG,InalFY, 2014.Prevention of etomidate induced myoclonus: Which is superior: Fentanyl, midazolam, or a combination? A Retrospective comparative study,Med Sci Monit 10 262 -267
0

Citations

0

Downloads

53

Views