No Detail Found!

Identifying the Barriers Between Researchers and Ethical review Committee: a Pilot Study.

Author(s)
Sadia Ahsin Department of Physiology, Foundation University Medical College, Islamabad,
Madiha Imran Department of Physiology, Foundation University Medical College, Islamabad,
Abstract
Background: Approval from Ethical Review Committee (ERC) has often been considered a challenge by researchers. Regular evaluation of ERC procedures has been recommended globally. We have evaluated working of ERC at Foundation University by identifying gaps between ERC and researchers with the vision to improve the efficiency of the committee. Methods: A cross sectional study was conducted, after permission from president ERC. We developed a structured feedback proforma with 20 questions regarding application form, its processing and over all experience of researchers. A total of 65 volunteer faculty members who had ever applied to ERC for approval, participated in study. A descriptive analysis was done using spreadsheets. Results: Out of 65 volunteers, 41 returned and completed the proforma. More than 50% (n=24) respondents considered application form was simple to comprehend, however, 40% (n=17) agreed that ERC should provide assistance in its completion. The good majority received final approval letter within one month of application however almost none received proper acknowledgement of receipt and notification of time taken for review. Two third participants (66%, n=27) showed confidence in ERC decisions. Improvement in communication between ERC and researchers through IT support was suggested. Conclusions: Researchers agreed that ERC at Foundation University with its limited resources was fulfilling its role of timely review process and showed confidence in its decisions. The communication lack between ERC and researchers was considered major weakness.
Publication Details
Page(s) 55-57
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Physiology, Volume: 14, Issue: 4, Year: 2018

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Eethical rreview process, communication gaps, researchers’ feedback
References
2002.International ethical guidelines for biomedical research involving human subjects,Bull Med Ethics 17 -23
SherinA, .Research ethics committees (RECs) and monitoring of biomedical research in Pakistan,Khyber Med Univ J 2013;s(3) 121 -2
JafareyAM,IqbalSP,HassanM., 2012.Ethical review in Pakistan: the credibility gap,J Pak Med Assoc 62 1355 -
2004.ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects,Int J Bioethics 15 124 -
LanteroDA,SchmelzJO,LongfieldJN, 2011.Using Metrics to Make an Impact in a Human Research Protection Program,J Clin Res Best Practice 7 1 -5
AdamsP,KaewkungwalJ,LimphattharacharoenC,PrakobthamS,PengsaaK,Khusmith S, 2014.Is your Ethics Committee efficient? Using “IRB Metrics” as a self-assessment tool for continuous improvement at the Faculty of Tropical Medicine,PloS One 9 e113356 -
AhsinS,SaeedGN, 2017.Self-evaluation of ethical review committee's functioning at Foundation University Medical College (FUMC) through structured constitution-practiceoutcome (CPO) assessment model,J Pak Med Association 67 42 -
NichollJ., 2000.The ethics of research ethics committee,BMJ 320 1217 -
AlbertiKGMM, 2000.Multicentre research ethics committees: has the cure been worse than the disease? No, but idiosyncracies and obstructions to good research must be removed,BMJ 320 1157 -8
AhmedAEH,NicholsonKG, 1996.Delays and diversity in the practice of local research ethics committees,J Med Ethics 22 263 -6
ColemanCH,BouësseauMC, 2008.How do we know that research ethics committees are really working? The neglected role of outcomes assessment in research ethics review,BMC Med Ethics 9 6 -
KandhariR., 2013.Justice in jeopardy: a qualitative study of institutional ethics committees in New Delhi,Indian J Med Ethics 10 176 -83
ZwietenMC,WillemsDL, 2012.Ethical review from the inside: repertoires of evaluation in Research Ethics Committee meetings,Sociol Health Illness 34 1039 -52
Procedures, .Policy-and-, -
0

Citations

0

Downloads

94

Views