No Detail Found!

Comparison of Academic Performance in Peer Assisted and Expert-assisted Learning through Test Scores.

Author(s)
Gule Naghma Saeed Department of Physiology, Foundation University Medical College, Islamabad, Pakistan
Sadia Ahsin Department of Physiology, Foundation University Medical College, Islamabad, Pakistan
Komal Saad Department of Physiology, Foundation University Medical College, Islamabad, Pakistan
Amir Afzal Foundation University, Islamabad, Pakistan
Abstract
Background: Peer Assisted Learning is being increasingly used in medical education as it is a wellestablished approach in learning. The objective of this study was to compare the effectiveness of Peer Assisted Learning with Expert-Assisted Learning in terms of assessment scores in first year MBBS students during their cardiovascular module. Methods: A cross-over study was carried out on 139 first year medical students at Foundation University Islamabad after ethical approval. The entire class constituted the sampling frame. Students were given an introductory lecture on Peer Assisted Learning methodology at the beginning of study. Three Peer Assisted Learning sessions were conducted in small groups with all students as an adjunct to traditional large group lectures, and in the fourth session all students went through pre-informed assessment comprising of short answer questions and multiple choice questions. In the next three weeks, same students went through conventional Expert-Assisted Learning sessions, followed by same type of assessment with different topics of the same module. The scores were compared. Mann-Whitney U test was used as a test of significance. Results: Test scores, represented as median (IQR), of the Peer-Assisted Learning and Expert-Assisted Learning sessions were 6.50 (5.00-7.50) and 7.00 (6.00-7.50) respectively (p=0.46). Pass percentages in these sessions were 82.9% (n=102) and 87.5% (n=105) respectively, with odds ratio of 0.69 and 95% confidence interval of 0.34 to 1.42. Conclusion: Academic performance of Peer-Assisted Learning sessions in terms of test scores was not better than Expert-Assisted Learning sessions.
Publication Details
Page(s) 47-50
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Physiology, Volume: 14, Issue: 4, Year: 2018

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
academic performance, test scores, Expert-Assisted Learning, Peer-assisted learning
References
Falchikov N., 2001.Learning together: Peer tutoring in higher education, -
1994.,New Directions Teach Learn 60 11 -21
EdwardsS,BoneJ, 2012.Integrating peer assisted learning and eLearning: Using innovative pedagogies to support learning and teaching in higher education settings,Aust J Teach Educ (Online) 37 1 -12
ArendaleDR, 2014.Understanding the Peer Assisted Learning Model: “Student Study Groups in Challenging College Courses”,Int J High Educ 3 1 -12
RossMT,CameronHS, 2007.Peer Assisted Learning: a planning and implementation framework:,AMEE Guide No. 30. Med Teach 29 527 -45
Ten CateO,DurningS. Dimensions, 2007.and psychology of peer teaching in medical education,Med Teach 29 546 -52
ShankarPR,SinghB,SinghAK,KarkiBS,ThapaTP, 2011.Student perception about peer-assisted learning sessions in a medical school in Nepal,WebmedCentral Med Educ 2 WMC002459 -
NaqiSA, 2014.Peer assisted learning as a formal instructional tool,J Coll Physicians Surg Pak 24 169 -72
SchmidtH,Van DerA rend A,KokxI,BoonL, 1994.Peer versus staff tutoring in problem-based learning,Instruct Sci 22 279 -85
ReesEL,QuinnPJ,DaviesB,FotheringhamV, 2016.How does peer teaching compare to faculty teaching? A systematic review and meta-analysis,Med Teach 38 829 -37
WeyrichP,CelebiN,SchrauthM,MöltnerA,LammerdingKöppelM,NikendeiC, 2009.Peer-assisted versus faculty staff-led skills laboratory training: a randomised controlled trial,Med Educ 43 113 -20
SteeleDJ,MedderJD,TurnerP., 2000.A comparison of learning outcomes and attitudes in student- versus faculty-led problem-based learning: an experimental study,Med Educ 34 23 -9
HodgsonY,BearmanM,Schneider-KolskyM, 2012.Lessons learned in implementing peer-assisted learning,Int J Innovat Sci Math Educ 20 19 -30
RossM,CummingA,DentJA,HardenRM, .A practical guide for medical teachers, -
2013., 134 -41
KommalageM,Thabrew H, 2011.Student-led peer-assisted learning: the Kuppi experience at the medical school of the University of Ruhuna in Sri Lanka,Educ Health 24 516 -
2006.Helping each other to learn -a process evaluation of peer assisted learning,BMC Med Educ 6 18 -
HammondJA,BithellCP,JonesL,BidgoodP., 2010.A first year experience of student-directed peer-assisted learning,Active Learn High Educ 11 201 -12
PeetsAD,CoderreS,WrightB,JenkinsD,BurakK,LeskoskyS, 2009.Involvement in teaching improves learning in medical students: a randomized cross-over study,BMC Med Educ 9 55 -
RiazI., 2014.Peer assisted versus expert assisted learning: a comparison of effectiveness in terms of academic scores,J Coll Physicians Surg Pak 24 825 -9
DaudS,ChaudhryAM,AliSK, 2016.Lecture based versus peer assisted learning: quasi-experimental study to compare knowledge gain of fourth year medical students in community health and nutrition course,Res Dev Med Educ 5 62 -8
ShahI,MahboobU,Shah S, 2017.Effectiveness of horizontal peerassisted learning in physical examination performance,J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad 29 559 -65
DaudS,AliSK, 2014.Perceptions of learners about peer assisted learning and lectures,Int J Sci Study (IJSR) 3 1449 -55
0

Citations

0

Downloads

123

Views