Different neem (Azadirachta indica L.) extracts (leaf and seed) and seed oils were tested against English grain aphid (Sitobionavenae F.) with a neonicotinoid, imidacloprid on wheat. All neem oils and neem seed kernel extract proved comparatively more effective in laboratory bioassay studies, with LC50 values ranging from 0.34 to 1.10%. In field-cage experiment, neem seed oil-hexane was statistically similar with imidacloprid followed by neem seed oil-expeller and neem seed kernel extract, while neem seed oil-ethanol was at par with imidacloprid. On the basis of cumulative insect days in field trials, neem seed oilexpeller proved as effective as imidacloprid in controlling the aphids, while except neem seed cake extract, all other treatments were statistically at par with imidacloprid. Non-significant differences were found in the population of mummified aphids between control and neem seed kernel extract, neem leaf extract, neem seed oil-hexane, neem seed cake extract and neem seed oil-expeller. There existed non-significant differences in all treatments regarding aphid predators. Maximum increase in wheat yield (7.28 q/ha) was observed in neem seed kernel extract treated plots followed by those of imidacloprid (7.23 q/ha). Application of imidacloprid resulted in maximum cost-benefit ratio (1:1.34) followed by that of neem seek kernel extract 5% (1:1.31). If the additional cost of loss of beneficial organisms and environmental risks posed by the application of synthetic insecticides is considered, the cost-benefit ratio of neem seed kernel extract may be comparable to that of imidacloprid and may be used against wheat aphids.