The relationship between trade liberalization and gender disparity in education: Evidence from Pakistan | [NURTURE • 2023]

Author(s):

1. Jabbar Ul-Haq: Department of Economics, University of Sargodha, Sargodha, Pakistan

2. Iqra Ashraf: Department of Economics, University of Sargodha, Sargodha, Pakistan

3. Ahmed Raza Cheema: Department of Economics, University of Sargodha, Sargodha, Pakistan

4. Qazi Muhammad Adnan Hye: Academic Research and Development Wing,Dubai,United Arab Emirates

5. Hubert Visas: School of International Trade & Economics, University of International Business and Economics,Beijing 100029,China

Abstract:

Over the past few decades, there has been an increasing interest in understanding the relationship between trade liberalization and gender inequality in developing countries. In Pakistan, due to its social, demographic, cultural and economic problems, gender disparity in education (GDE) is still prevalent. This study examines the impact of trade reforms on gender disparity in education using micro data from Pakistan. Design/Methodology/Approach: The feasible generalized least-squares (FGLS) method is employed for empirical analysis. We used panel corrected standard errors (PCSEs) for robustness checks. Findings: The analysis reveals that a reduction in import tariffs is associated with GDE. Trade liberalization gives rise to gender disparities. We added several control variables to the baseline model for robustness checks. Regarding the control variables, average family wage income, family size, urbanization, female-to-male labor force participation and the female share of the total labor force are identified as important determinants of GDE in Pakistan. Originality or Value: This study contributes to the existing literature by studying the relationship between trade liberalization and gender disparity in education in Pakistan and employing a better measure of reductions in import tariffs for trade liberalization. We construct a provincial liberalization index. Second, this study takes into account the whole trade regime as a sample period (i.e., from 1990-2005) to assess the impacts of the trade regime as protection rates significantly reduced through this regime. Third, we measure the gender gap in education by comparing males and females' average years of schooling as opposed to previous studies that used secondary school enrolment ratios as a proxy for the gender gap in education. Fourth, we used panel data to explore the impact of trade liberalization on gender disparity in education for empirical analysis.

Page(s): 180-193

DOI: 10.55951/nurture.v17i3.291

Published: Journal: NURTURE, Volume: 17, Issue: 3, Year: 2023

Keywords:

Pakistan , Panel Data Analysis , Gender disparity , Educational inequality , Provincial liberalization index , Trade reforms

References:

[1] Acemoglu D.,Pischke J.-S. .2001 .Changes in the wage structure, family income, and children's education. European Economic Review, 2921(01) : 00115-5.

[2] Ahmed N.,Hyder K. .2006 .Gender inequality and trade liberalization: A case study of Pakistan. Forman Journal of Economics Studies, 2(1) : 28-38.

[3] Akhtar Z. .2012 .Socio-economic status factors effecting the students achievement: A predictive study. International Journal of Social Sciences and Education, 2(1) : 281-287.

[4] Alderman H.,Gertler P. .1989 .The substitutability of public and private health care for the treatment of children in Pakistan: The World Bank. , 57 : .

[5] Alderman H.,King E. M. .1998 .Gender differences in parental investment in education. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 9(4) : 453-468.

[6] Arora R. U. .2012 .Gender inequality, economic development, and globalization: A state level analysis of India. The Journal of Developing Areas, 46(1) : 147-164.

[7] Aziz M.,Bloom D. E.,Humair S.,Jimenez E.,Rosenberg L.,Sathar Z. .2014 .Education system reform in Pakistan: Why, when, and how? IZA Policy Paper No. 76. IZA Institute of Labor Economics. , : .

[8] Baliamoune M.,McGillivray M. .2014 .The impact of gender inequality in education on income in Africa and the Middle East. Economic Modelling, 11 : 11.

[9] Baluch M. U. H.,Shahid S. .2008 .Determinants of enrollment in primary education. Pakistan Economic and Social Review, 46(2) : 161-200.

[10] Bank W. .2001 .Engendering development. , : .

[11] Barro R.,Lee J.-W. .2000 .International data on education attainment: Updates and implications center of international development at Harvard. , : .

[12] Barro R. J.,Lee J.-W. .1994 .Sources of economic growth. Paper presented at the At the Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy., : .

[13] Beck N.,Katz J. N. .1995 .What to do (and not to do) with time-series cross-section data. American Political Science Review, 89(3) : 634-647.

[14] Becker G. S. .1962 .Investment in human capital: A theoretical analysis. Journal of Political Economy, 70(5) : 9-49.

[15] Berik G.,Rodgers Y. V. D. M.,Seguino S. .2009 .Feminist economics of inequality, development, and growth. Feminist Economics, 15(3) : 1-33.

[16] Bhagwati J. .1964 .The pure theory of international trade: A survey. The Economic Journal, 74(293) : 1-84.

[17] Busse M.,Nunnenkamp P. .2009 .Gender disparity in education and the international competition for foreign direct investment. Feminist Economics, 15(3) : 61-90.

[18] Busse M.,Spielmann C. .2006 .Gender inequality and trade. Review of International Economics, 14(3) : 362-379.

[19] Bussmann M. .2008 .The effect of trade openness on women's welfare and work life. World Development, 10(6) : 1027-1038.

[20] Bussolo M.,Freije S.,Djiofack C.,Rodríguez M. .2011 .Trade openness and labor gender gaps in DR-CAFTA countries. , : .

[21] Camp-Yeakey C. .2012 .Living on the boundaries: Urban marginality in national. , : 8.

[22] Castilho M.,Menéndez M.,Sztulman A. .2011 .Trade liberalization, inequality, and poverty in Brazilian states. World Development, 09(4) : 821-835.

[23] Chant S.,McIlwaine C. .2013 .-development-and-the-politics-of-space/. , : .

[24] Chant S.,McIlwaine C. .2015 .Cities, slums and gender in the global south: Towards a feminised urban future: Routledge.. , : .

[25] Chaudhry I. S. .2007 .Gender inequality in education and economic growth: Case study of Pakistan. Pakistan Horizon, 60(4) : 81-91.

[26] Hassan M. S.,Bukhari S.,Arshed N. .2020 .Competitiveness, governance and globalization: What matters for poverty alleviation? Environment, Development. , 22(4) : 3491-3518.

[27] Hill M. A.,King E. .1995 .Women's education and economic well-being. Feminist Economics, 1(2) : 21-46.

[28] Imran M. .2015 .Barriers to human capital development: Measurements, gender disparities and determinants: A study of towns and districts of Punjab. Working Paper of Shahid Javed Burki Institute of Public Policy. , : .

[29] Iqbal Z.,Mughal K. S.,Aslam F.,Khan M. M.,Mohmand Y. T. .2020 .Globalization and gender equality in terms of education and employment: A case of selected asian developing countries. International Transaction Journal of Engineering Management & Applied Sciences & Technologies, 11(2) : 1-10.

[30] Juhn C.,Ujhelyi G.,Villegas-Sanchez C. .2013 .Men, women, and machines: How trade impacts gender inequality. Journal of Development Economics, 09 : 179-193.

[31] Kar S. K.,Somani A. .2008 .Impact of rapid urbanization on women's mental health: A review of literature. , 18(1) : 171-176.

[32] Klasen S. .2002 .Low schooling for girls, slower growth for all? Cross‐country evidence on the effect of gender inequality in education on economic development. The World Bank Economic Review, 16(3) : 345-373.

[33] Klasen S.,Lamanna F. .2009 .The impact of gender inequality in education and employment on economic growth: New evidence for a panel of countries. Feminist Economics, 15(3) : 91-132.

[34] Kmenta J.,Klein L. R. .1971 .Elements of econometrics. , 655 : .

[35] Knodel J.,Havanon N.,Sittitrai W. .1990 .Family size and the education of children in the context of rapid fertility decline. Population and Development Review, 16(1) : 31-209.

[36] Knodel J.,Wongsith M. .1991 .Family size and children's education in Thailand: Evidence from a national sample. Demography, 28(1) : 119-131.

[37] Konuk N.,Turan N. G.,Ardali Y. .2016 .The importance of urbanization in education. The Eurasia Proceedings of Educational and Social Sciences, 5 : 232-236.

[38] Korinek J.,Publishing OECD .2005 .Trade and gender: Issues and interactions. Retrieved from OECD Trade Policy Papers, No. 24, : .

[39] Kucera D.,Milberg W. .2000 .Gender segregation and gender bias in manufacturing trade expansion: Revisiting the" wood asymmetry". World Development, 28(00) : 00020-6.

[40] Lagerlöf N.-P. .2003 .Gender equality and long-run growth. Journal of Economic Growth, 4(8) : 403-426.

[41] Lane D.,Roberts K.,B K. .2008 .Use of Political Economy Indicators. , : .

[42] Lloyd C. B. .1993 .Fertility, family size, and structureconsequences for families and children. Paper presented at the Paper Presented at the Seminar Proceedings of a Population Council11992, : .

[43] Maddala G.,Lahiri K. .2006 .Introduction to econometrics. , 67 : .

[44] Mahmood Z. .1997 .9:1%3C85::aid-jid223%3E3.0. Journal of International Development, 9(199701) : u-1328.

[45] Mahmood Z.,Azhar M. .2001 .On overinvoicing of exports in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review, 40(3) : 173-185.

[46] Marcoux A. .1998 .The feminization of poverty: Claims, facts, and data needs. Population and Development Review, 24(1) : 131-139.

[47] Michael L. .1983 .Demography and poverty (English). Staff working paper; No. SWP, : .

[48] Miljkovic D.,Kassouf S. H.,Oliveira A. L.,F. C. A. L. .2017 .Determinants of obesity in Brazil: The effects of trade liberalization and socio-economic variables. Applied Economics, 50(28) : 3076-3088.

[49] Mincer J. .1974 .Schooling, experience, and earnings. Retrieved from Human Behavior & Social Institutions No. 2., : .

[50] Mussida C.,Picchio M. .2014 .The gender wage gap by education in Italy. The Journal of Economic Inequality, 12(1) : 117-147.

[51] Naranpanawa A.,Arora R. .2014 .Does trade liberalization promote regional disparities? Evidence from a multiregional CGE model of India. World Development, 06 : 349.

[52] Parks R. W. .1967 .Efficient estimation of a system of regression equations when disturbances are both serially and contemporaneously correlated. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 62(318) : 500-509.

[53] Qian N. .2008 .Missing women and the price of tea in China: The effect of sex-specific earnings on sex imbalance. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123(3) : 1251-1285.

[54] Reichlin L.,Shaw E. .2015 .Gender, urbanisation and democratic governance. Retrieved from Institute for Women's Policy Research. , : .

[55] Rice J. S. .2010 .Free trade, fair trade and gender inequality in less developed countries. Sustainable Development, 18(1) : 42-50.

[56] Robbins D.,Retrieved D. .2003 .The impact of trade liberalization upon inequality in developing countries-a review of theory and. , 13 : .

[57] Sajid S. .2014 .Does trade openness advances gender equality in education: A case of D8 countries. Journal Global & Science Issues, 2(2) : 1-24.

[58] Schultz T. P. .2014 .Does the liberalization of trade advance gender equality in schooling and health? Retrieved from IZA DP No. 2140, IZA Institute of Labor Economics. , : .

[59] Seguino S. .2000 .Gender inequality and economic growth: A cross-country analysis. World Development, 28(00) : 00018-8.

[60] Servin-Gonzalez M.,Torres-Reyna O. .1999 .Trends: Religion and politics. The Public Opinion Quarterly, 63(4) : 592-621.

[61] Sheikh M. A. .1974 .. Underinvoicing of imports in Pakistan. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 36(4) : 287-296.

[62] Shi J.,Visas H.,Ul-Haq J.,Abbas S.,Khanum S. .2022 .Investigating the impact of export product diversification on environmental degradation: Evidence from chinese provinces. Environment, Development and Sustainability, : 1-32.

[63] Siddiqui A.,Iram U. .2007 .Socioeconomic determinants of school progression in Pakistan. Applied Econometrics and International Development, 7(2) : 179-192.

[64] Siddiqui A. H.,Iqbal J. .2005 .Impact of trade openness on output growth for Pakistan: An empirical investigation. Retrieved from MPRA DP No. 23757., : .

[65] Siddiqui R. .2009 .Modeling gender effects of Pakistan's trade liberalization. Feminist Economics, 15(3) : 287-321.

[66] Thomas D. .1990 .Intra-household resource allocation: An inferential approach. Journal of Human Resources, 25(4) : 635-664.

[67] Topalova P. .2007 .Trade liberalization, poverty and inequality: Evidence from Indian districts globalization and poverty. , : 291-336.

[68] Ul-Haq J. .2016 .Trade liberalization, wages and work environment nexus: Evidences from Pakistan. , : .

[69] Ul-Haq J.,Khanum S.,Raza Cheema A. .2020 .The impact of trade liberalization on child labor in Pakistan. International Review of Applied Economics, 34(6) : 769-784.

[70] Ul-Haq J.,Wajid F.,Visas H.,Cheema A. R.,Abbas S. .2022 .The nexus between trade liberalization and poverty: A disaggregated analysis. Asian Economic and Financial Review, 12(4) : 4481-295.

[71] Umer F. .2014 .Impact of trade openness on economic growth of Pakistan: An ARDL approach. Journal of Business & Economic Policy, 1(1) : 39-59.

[72] UNDP. .2010 .United nations development programme-human development report 2010. , : .

[73] UNICEF. .2015 .The investment case for education and equity. , : .

[74] Rahman Ur,Chaudhry S.,Farooq I. S.,F. I. S. .2018 .Gender inequality in education and household poverty in Pakistan: A case of Multan district. Review of Economics and Development Studies, 4(1) : 286-126.

[75] Wamboye E. F.,Seguino S. .2014 .Gender effects of trade openness in Sub-Saharan Africa. Feminist Economics, 21(3) : 82-113.

[76] Watch W. .2011 .Gender equality and trade tolicy resource paper: United nations inter-agency network on women and gender equality. , : .

[77] Wolff J. R.,Gordon E. W. .2008 .Comprehensive educational equity: The path to meaningful opportunity for excellence. Paper presented at the Comprehensive Educational Equity: Overcoming the Socioeconomic Barriers to School Success Equity Symposium. , : .

[78] Wood A.,Ridao-Cano C. .1999 .. international inequality. Oxford Economic Papers, 51(1) : 89-119.

[79] Wu M.,Ul-Haq J.,Zafar N. U.,Sun H.,Jiang J. .2019 .Trade liberalization and informality nexus: Evidence from Pakistan. The Journal of International Trade & Economic Development, 28(6) : 732-754.

[80] Xing W.,Zhou L. A. .2018 .Bilateral trust and trade: Evidence from China. , 41(8) : 1918-1940.

[81] Yamamura E. .2016 .Long-term effect of international trade on the gender wage and educational gaps. Retrieved from ISER Discussion Paper No, 963 : .

Citations

Downloads

Views