A hybrid Approach of Data Envelopment Analysis Based Grey Relational Analysis: a Study on Egg Yield. | [Pakistan Journal of Zoology • 2019]

Author(s):

1. Hande Kknder: Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Bartın University, Ağdacı Campus 74000, Bartın, Turkey

2. Pnarelebi Demirarslan: Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Bartın University, Ağdacı Campus 74000, Bartın, Turkey

3. Aykut Burgut: Faculty of Agriculture, Çukurova University, Yüreğir 01230, Adana, Turkey

4. Mustafa Boa: Bor Vocational School, Niğde University, Bor 51700, Niğde, Turkey

Abstract:

The aim of the study is to evaluate the effect of conditions of both feeding and the climate in poultry house on production performance in a commercial poultry enterprise with a hybrid approach. In accordance with this purpose, the hybrid approach has two main objectives: i) Determination of the effective period for which the output factors [(chicken survival rate (%), egg yield (%)] are optimized at the same time and the appropriate value ranges for the input factors [temperature (oC), humidity (%) and feed per hen (g)] that provide effectiveness ii) Determination of targeted improvement values for the ineffective months to become effective. With this hybrid approach, which is based on the integration of the Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) and Grey Relational Analysis (GRA), the effective months are determined by DEA method and a performance rank is performed between the effective months by GRA method. It has been investigated whether the results of different Multicriteria Decision Making (MCDM) techniques combined with the data fusion technique support the proposed hybrid approach's results. In this context, the proposed hybrid approach was applied to evaluate the monthly production performance of a commercial enterprise with Lohman Brown genus 8000 chickens. According to the findings of the analysis, it was seen that January, March, October, November and December are the months when production performance is high. When these months were ranked among themselves, it was observed that January, March and November are the first three ranks, respectively, and that the rank was also supported by the combined results of different techniques. As a result, in terms of production performance for the enterprise, it can be said that the optimum temperature is 20.25°C-26.41°C, humidity ratio is 47.60%-54.25%, and feed amount per hen is 98-128 g.

Page(s): 903-912

DOI: 10.17582/journal.pjz/2019.51.3.903.912

Published: Journal: Pakistan Journal of Zoology, Volume: 51, Issue: 3, Year: 2019

Keywords:

temperature , humidity , Laying hen , DEA , CRITIC , GRA

References:

[1] Anonymous, 2018.B1l%C4%B1k/Kanatl%C4%B1%20Yeti%C5%9Ftiricili%C4%9Fi/YumurtaTavukculugu,(accessed 18 March -

[2] Anonymous, 2018.Laying hens. Ministry of Agriculture and Foresty: İstanbul Directorate of Provincial Agriculture and Foresty,pdf (accessed 18 March -

[3] Ayaydın , H.,Durmuş , S.,Pala , F., 2017.Performance on measurement in Turkish logistics ındustry with grade relative analysis method,Gümüşhane Univ. Elect. J. Inst. Soc. Sci. 8 76 -94

[4] Bayhan , A.K.,Karaman , S., 2013.Effects of heat stress on egg yield and mortality rates of caged poultry houses,J. Facul. Vet. Med 19 881 -887

[5] Brauers , W.K.,Zavadskas , E.K., 2006.The MOORA method and its application to privatization in a transition economy,Contr 35 445 -469

[6] Bulancak , A.,Baylan , M.,Anim, 2015.Negative Impacts of the high temperature-humidity in poultry and precautions, 56 58 -69

[7] Cooper , W.W.,Seiford , L.M.,Tone , K., 2006.Introduction to data envelopment analysis and ıts uses with DEA-solver software and references, -

[8] Çakır , S.,Perçin , S., 2013.Performance measurement of logistics firms with multi-criteria decision making methods,Ege Acad. Rev. 13 449 -459

[9] Depren, 2008.Data envelopment analysis and an application,Unpublished Master thesis -

[10] Diakoulaki , D.,Mavrotas , G.,Papayannakis , L., 1995.Determining objective weights in multiple criteria problems: The critic method,Comput. Operat. Res. 22 00059 -H

[11] Duru , M.,Şahin , A., 2015.Effects of dietary ferula eleaochytris powder on yield and egg quality in laying hens,Iğdır Univ. J. Inst. Sci. Technol 5 99 -109

[12] Gevrekci , Y.,Takma , C., 2018.A comparative study for egg production in layers by decision tree analysis,Pakistan J. Zool. 50 437 -437

[13] Girginer , N.,Köse , T.,Uçkun , N., 2015.Efficiency analysis of surgical services by combined use of data envelopment analysis and gray relational analysis,J. med 39 56 -

[14] Gök , M., 2015.Ranking g20 countries with regard to energy indicators via multiple criteria decision making techniques,Unpublished Master thesis -

[15] Hsu , C.J.,Huang, 2006.Comparison and assessment of ımproved grey relation analysis for software development effort estimation,IEEE International Conference on Management of Innovation and Technology 663 -667

[16] Jahan , A.,Mustapha , F.,Sapuan , S.M.,Ismail, 2012.A framework for weighting of criteria in ranking stage of material selection process,Int. J. Adv. Manufact. Technol. 58 411 -420

[17] Karaatlı , M., 2016.An ıntegrated entropy-gray relational analysis approach: A study on tourism ındustry,Suleyman Demirel Univ. J. Facul. Econ. Admin. Sci. 21 63 -77

[18] Karaman , S.,Ergüneş , G.,Turhan , S., 2005.The status and development possibilities of strructural and environmental conditions of caged houses in Tokat area,J. Agric. Facul 22 67 -76

[19] Kılıç,Şimşek , E., 2008.A study on determination of sufficiency of ındoor environmental conditions in a layer house with deep-pit,J. Agric. Facul 22 17 -29

[20] Markabi , M.S.,Sabbagh , M., 2014.A hybrid method of GRA and DEA for evaluating and selecting efficient suppliers plus a novel ranking method for grey numbers,J. indust. Engin. Manage. 7 1197 -1221

[21] Motiang , I.B., 2013.Evaluation of different chicken layer breeds for use in integrated aquaculturepoultry production systems in Gauteng, South Africa,Faculty of Natural and Agricultural Sciences -

[22] Özden , A., 2016.Performance level determination of dairy farms using dea,Turkish J. agric. Econ. 22 49 -55

[23] Özkan , G., 2013.An aplication in the field of animal breeding in order to compare fuzzy TOPSIS and AHP methods,Master thesis -

[24] Pakkar , S.M., 2016.An integrated approach to grey relational analysis, analytic hierarchy process and data envelopment analysis,Busi. Econ. Res. J. 9 71 -86

[25] Ran , R.,Wang , B.J., 2015.Combining grey relational analysis and TOPSIS concepts for evaluating the technical innovation capability of high technology enterprises with fuzzy information,J. Intell. Fuzz. Syst. 29 1301 -1309

[26] Reig-Martinez , E.,Picazo-Tadeo , A.J., 2003.Analyzing farming systems with data envelopment analysis: Citrus farming in Spain, 12 17 -30

[27] Romero , L.F.,Zuidhof , M.J.,Jeffrey , S.R.,Naeima , A.,Renema , R.A.,Robinson , F.E., 2010.A data envelope analysis to assess factors affecting technical and economic efficiency of ındividual broiler breeder hens,Poult. Sci. 89 00391 -1777

[28] Saçaklı , P.,TAV U K - B E S L E M E - P I N A R - S A C A K L I ., 2018.p d f (accessed 18 March, -

[29] Sefeedpari , P.,Rafiee , S.,Akram , A., 2012.Selecting energy efficient poultry egg producers: A fuzzy data envelopment analysis approach,Int. J. appl. Operat. Res. 2 77 -88

[30] Silva , D.A.,Alves , G.I.,Mattos-Neto , P.S.,Ferreira , T.A., 2014.Measurement of fitness function efficiency using data envelopment analysis,Exp. Syst. Appl. 06 7147 -7160

[31] Sivarajah , P., 2017.Farm efficiency measurement of paddy production in Northern Sri Lanka using data envelopment analysis (DEA) approach,Int. J. Res. Granthaalayah 5 164 -170

[32] Şimşek , A.,Çatır , O.,Ömürbek , N., 2015.Vendor choice with TOPSIS and MOORA methods: A practice in tourism sector,J. Soc. Sci. Inst 18 133 -161

[33] Takma,Gevrekçi , Y.,Özsoy , A.N.,Çevik , M., 2017.Canonical correlation analysis on egg production traits of quails,Süleyman Demirel Üniv. Ziraat Fakül 12 92 -99

[34] Todsadee , A.,Kameyama , H.,Ngamsomsuk , K.,Yamauchi , K., 2012.Production efficiency of broiler farming in Thailand: A stochastic frontier approach,J. agric. Sci. 4 221 -231

[35] Tone , K., 2001.A slacks-based measure of efficiency in data envelopment analysis,Eur. J. Operat. Res. 2217 00407 -5

[36] Topal , M.,Yağanoğlu , A.M., 2018.Comparison of quality characteristics ın honey using grey relational and principal component analysis methods,J. Anim. Pl. Sci. 28 264 -269

[37] Topal , M.,Özdemir , M.,Yaganoglu , A.M.,Esenbuga , N., 2016.Comparison of the sensory characteristics ın Awassi and Red Karaman sheep with the grey relational analysis method,J. Anim. Pl. Sci. 26 63 -68

[38] Tsaur , R.C.,Chen , I.,Chan , Y.S., 2016.TFT-LCD industry performance analysis and evaluation using GRA and DEA models,Int. J. Prod. Res. 1252 4378 -4391

[39] Uğurlu , N.,Kara , M., 2000.The cooling performance of wet pads and their effect on reduction of the ınside temperature,Turkish J. Agric. Forest. 24 79 -86

[40] Uğurlu , N.,Kara , M., 2002.The effects of stocking density and thermal conductivity on ventilatıon rate of laying hens,J. Selçuk Univ. Agric. Facul. 16 59 -64

[41] Wu , H.H., 2002.A comparative study of using grey relational analysis in multiple attribute decision making problems, 15 209 -217

[42] Yalçın , N.,Ünlü , U., 2016.A multi-criteria performance analysis of ınitial public offering (IPO) ifrms using CRITIC and VIKOR methods,Technol. econ. Develop 24 534 -560

[43] Yıldız , A.,Laçin , E.,Esenbuğa , N.,Kocaman , B.,Macit , M., 2013.Effect of tier level on the performance and egg quality traits of laying hens in different seasons,Atatürk Univ. J. Vet. Sci. 8 145 -152

[44] Yıldız , T.,Ceylan , N., 2015.The effect of using gamma ırradiated wheat and barley in layer diets on egg product parameters quality,Turkish J. Agric. Fd. Sci. Technol 3 456 -747

[45] Zavadskas , E.K.,Turskis , Z., 2010.A new additive ratio assessment (ARAS) method in multicriteria decision-making,Technol. Econ. Develop. Economy 16 159 -172

[46] Zhai , L.Y.,Khoo , L.P.,Zhong , Z.W., 2009.Design concept evaluation in product development using rough sets and grey relation analysis,Exp. Syst. Appl. 36 7072 -7079

Citations

Downloads

Views